Tibetan Centre for Human Rights and Democracy

Human Rights Update and Archives

November 2002

Tibetan prisoner of conscience dies in detention  [ read ]
Profile of a current political prisoner
Farmers incarcerated for peaceful independence demonstration  [ read ]
China thwarts Buddhist Lama's India visit  [ read ]
Political incident at a "patriotic education" session  [ read ]
Exile Tibetan detained for entry into Tibet [ read ]  [ read ]
Escapee's experiences across the border [ read ]  [ read ]
A prisoner flees from Drapchi Prison Hospital [ read ]  [ read ]
TCHRD Activities
TCHRD briefs EU First Secretary in India [ read ]  [ read ]
Orientation to TCHRD staff on refugee law [ read ]  [ read ]

Tibetan prisoner of conscience dies in detention

According to a reliable information received from Tibet, Lobsang Dhargyal died Monday morning, 19 November 2002, in a "reform through labour" camp in Siling Town, Machen County (Ch: Maqin xian), Golog "Tibet Autonomous Prefecture" ("TAP"), Qinghai Province.

He was serving 16 years' prison term on alleged charges of espionage and "splittist activities". He had earlier served two and half years' sentence for advocating Tibet's independence.

Although Tibetan Centre for Human Rights and Democracy (TCHRD) is yet to receive detailed information, it is almost certain that Lobsang Dhargyal's sudden demise is due to torture and maltreatment in the forced labour camp. It was reported that he suffered brain haemorrhage at the time of death.

The camp where Dhargyal was incarcerated is a Manufacturing Unit for Hydro-Electricity Power Plant. More updates on his death shall follow upon receiving further information.

The prevalence of torture as a reprisal for political activities is of great concern especially in light of the People's Republic of China's (PRC) obligations with regard to the Convention Against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman and Degrading Treatment or Punishment (CAT).

Although the PRC had ratified CAT in 1988, TCHRD records indicate total number of 79 known deaths both in custody and after release as a direct result of torture since 1986.

The continued abuse and torture of Tibetans in Chinese administered prisons and detention centres in Tibet imply that the Chinese government is bent on suppressing nationalist sentiments of the Tibetan people. Individual rights and rule of law seem only to concur within that parameter.

The Chinese criminal system has traditionally laid a strong emphasis on "Laogai" - "reform through labour". In 1994, the National People's Congress of the PRC promulgated a Prison Law that officially outlawed the "Laoga"i system. However, the system remains under the terminology of "Prison".

The basic aim of the "laogai" system was not simply punishment but also "reform and change for the better". Inmates of both prisons and labour camps (which are now both classified as prisons) are subjected to intensive labour requirements and ideological training that are considered effective tools to diminish individual political zeal and to create business profits.

Brief background of Lobsang Dhargyal

Lobsang Dhargyal was a former monk of Rabgya Monastery in Machen County in Golog "TAP". Born to Shergyam and Tsodon in 1962, Dhargyal engaged in nomadic works and studied Tibetan language when he was young.

His father was a strong advocate of Tibet's independence and was involved in many "reactionary" activities following Communist China's annexation of Tibet in 1959. His father committed suicide in 1970 to evade arrest by Chinese authorities.

In the post 1987 pro-independence campaign, Dhargyal, with monk friends Lobsang Palden and Yeshi Gyaltsen, printed approximately 40,000 pro-independence leaflets of slogans such as "Free Tibet" and "China, Quit Tibet".

On 15 November 1992, a grand enthronement ceremony for the then 13-year-old Shingsang Tenzin Choekyi Gyaltsen Rinpoche was scheduled to be held at Rabgya Monastery. Shingsang Rinpoche, head of Rabgya Monastery and the 20th reincarnation of the mother of Jetsongkhapa, the founder of Gelug School of Tibetan Buddhism, is considered one of the leading lamas in Qinghai Province.

On the eve of the ceremony, Dhargyal and his companions pasted and distributed the leaflets in strategic places such as public roads; street, malls and circumambulation route around Rabgya Monastery. A Tibetan national flag was hoisted on the rooftop of the monastery's chapel and a small paper flag was pasted at the corner.

The next evening, Public Security Bureau (PSB) officers from Machen County and Golog "TAP" interrogated all the monks. Ten days later on 25 November 1992, Dhargyal was arrested. Wooden block prints used in printing the leaflets were discovered from his room. However, his friends managed to escape.

After a year's detention in Golog Prison, Golog Intermediate People's Court sentenced Dhargyal to three years' imprisonment with two year deprivation of political rights. During the entire period of his imprisonment, Dhargyal was handcuffed and his feet were manacled. He lost his two front teeth as a result of severe beatings. On 25 May 1995, Lobsang Dhargyal was released on medical grounds six months before his due date of release.

The Tibetan Youth Congress based in Dharamsala, conferred upon Lobsang Dhargyal, Lobsang Palden and Yeshi Gyaltsen the Martyr's Award in August 1995, in recognition of their courageous deeds and sacrifices for Tibet.

In early 1997, Rabgya Monastery had come under heavy restrictions and surveillance. Therefore, in April 1997, Dhargyal fled Tibet to escort Shingsang Rinpoche to Sera Monastery in South India.

In May 2001, while returning to Tibet to visit his ailing mother, Lobsang Dhargyal was arrested somewhere near Shigatse in "Tibet Autonomous Region" ("TAR"). He was subsequently handed over to Golog "TAP" authorities. In October of the same year, Golog Intermediate People's Court sentenced Lobsang Dhargyal to a 16-year prison term for allegedly engaging in espionage and splittist activities.

A recent escapee from Tibet, 29-year-old Lobsang Tsultrim, recalls, "In April 2001, I was returning to Tibet with Lobsang Dhargyal and Tashi Gyatso via Solukhumbu, Nepal-Tibet border, when the Chinese border police detained us. When they began to hit us, we fought back and thus managed to escape. Unfamiliar with the routes, we ran to different directions."

"Dhargyal was arrested near old Tingri County (Dingri xian) in Shigatse 'TAP'; I was arrested in new Tingri County and Tashi Gyatso in Golog after he had returned home. After five days' detention in Nyari Detention Centre, three police officers escorted Dhargyal to Amdo Golog. That was the last time I saw him. He looked healthy at the time," continued Tsultrim.

Another escapee, Tenzin, from Rabgya Monastery went to visit Lobsang Dhargyal in early June 2002. He reported to TCHRD, "Since Dhargyal was my friend, I went to visit him in the detention centre. Though I don't know the name of the detention centre, I know that it is located between Siling and Dharthong County. I sent 500 yuan and some eatables for Dhargyal through a guard, as face-to-face meeting was not permitted. Later on, I received a note from Dhargyal stating that he had received the items. I recognised Dhargyal's signature on the note. I believe it had not been long since he was taken to the Manufacturing Unit of Hydro-Electricity Power Plant in Siling."

Lobsang Tsultrim, the former informant, is skeptical about the nature of Dhargyal's death. He told TCHRD,

"I believe Dhargyal did not die naturally. I also think, since his arrest, his parents and relatives were not allowed to see him at all. It is inevitable that he suffered torture and maltreatment in the prison.

"Dhargyal was a very good man. He was sociable and got along with everyone. He was very well-educated and had a great sense of patriotism. I was shocked by the news of his untimely death. Every Tibetan should strive to live up to his role. His image comes to my mind even today.:

In an earlier information received by TCHRD, four exile returnees - Mathok Damchoe (27), Sonam Gyatso (34), Kunchok Dhargyal (32) and Tsultrim Dhargyal (26) - all from Rabgya Monastery, were sentenced to six years' imprisonment.

The latest report says that the first three monks were sentenced to six years while Tsultrim Dhargyal received five years' term. Chinese authorities view the act of visiting India for pilgrimage and study with suspicion of "splittist" activities. Speculation is also rife that these people are suspected to have had close associations with Lobsang Dhargyal.

Other arrests and detention

After his arrest at new Tingri County in May 2001, 29-year-old Lobsang Tsultrim was detained in Nyari Detention Centre in Shigatse "TAP" for almost two months.

Tsultrim was arrested for bringing politically significant materials into China; small information booklets by Tibetan Government-in-exile, photos of the Dalai Lama, and copies of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights.

Tsultrim was later transferred to Golog Detention Centre and detained for two additional months. The prison authorities manacled his feet for over a month and shocked him with electric cattle prods during interrogations.

Around September 2001, Golog Intermediate People's Court sentenced Tsultrim to three years' prison term. He was released within 20 days of the sentence announcement. His family and relatives paid 15,000 yuan to secure his bail. He is originally from Amdo Golog.

Tashi Gyatso, a layperson from Dalang Township in Machen County is currently in Golog Prefecture Prison serving a total sentence of 12 years.

During their first encounter with the police in Solukhumbu, Gyatso had Tibetan national flags, an autobiography of the Dalai Lama, and other politically significant books. On account of possession of "political" items, he was arrested in Golog after his escape from the encounter. He is regarded as one of the political prisoner with the harshest sentence in the whole of Qinghai.

[ top ]

Farmers incarcerated for peaceful independence demonstration

Lhundrup Dorjee, born in 1968, is a farmer from Dasher Village in Meldrogungkar County.

On 30 June 1992, Dorjee along with three other companions disrupted a political "re-education" meeting in the village of Meldro Gyama Trikhang in Meldrogungkar County. The other three companions were Sonam Dorjee, Sonam Rinchen and Konchok Lodroe. They are all farmers from Dasher Village and in their thirties.

The Chinese authorities organise meetings for the villagers and "educate" them about communist ideologies and propogate Chinese version of the Tibetan history.

The four farmers rushed on stage, seized the microphone, and wrestled with the officials. They shouted pro-independence slogans and anti-Chinese statements exhibiting a Tibetan national flag. Soon thereafter, People's Armed Police (PAP) rushed to the scene to arrest the demonstrators.

After the four demonstrators had been dragged away and beaten by the PAP, approximately one hundred villagers began to shout pro-independence slogans.

Thupten Yeshi, a farmer from Meldrogungkar County, was formally arrested on 14 July 1992. Though Yeshi did not take part in the protest on 30 June 1992, he was suspected to be the "ringleader" of the protest. He was accused of other political activities as well.

On 20 October 1992, the five farmers faced trial in Lhasa Intermediate People's Court were sentenced.

Lhundrup Dorjee was severely injured during the protest, and was sentenced to 15-year prison term with five years' deprivation of political rights.

Thupten Yeshi was sentenced to 15 year's imprisonment and five years' deprivation of political rights. Kunchok, Sonam Dorjee, and Sonam Rinchen were all sentenced to 13 years' imprisonment and four years' deprivation of political rights.

Sonam Rinchen died in January 2000 while still in prison, after falling sick for more than three years without receiving medical treatment.

Kunchok Dorjee was released on medical parole in 1996. Lhundrup Dorjee, Thupten Yeshi, and Sonam Dorjee are currently serving their sentences in Drapchi Prison.

[ top ]

China thwarts Buddhist Lama's India visit

Tsewang Gyurmay, 24, originates from a family of pastoral nomad in Nyarong County (Xinlong xian), Karze "TAP", Sichuan Province.

Gyurmay told TCHRD, "Between 10 to 17 years of age, I had private tuition from my uncle on Tibetan language. Three years later, I joined Tsurphu Retreat Centre in Nyarong. I also got the opportunity to study in Serthar Buddhist Institute for three years."

Gyurmay reported that an influential Rinpoche was denied visa to travel to India for reasons known only to the officials. It is however widely speculated that Rinpoche's faith in the Dalai Lama could have evoked Chinese concern about 'splittist' influences in India.

"Delong Rinpoche, a 70-year-old renowned religious practitioner from Nyarong, is a revered lama of Lhapo Monastery in Nyarong. Rinpoche was born to a Chinese couple in Jasang Khang area in China. Rinpoche began his religious studies in Kartop Monastery in Derge County (Dege xian) in Karze. The monastery follows Nyingma School of Tibetan Buddhism.

"I had his blessings and know that he is a close associate of Khenpo Jigme Phuntsok, the chief abbot and founder of Serthar Buddhist Institute. Rinpoche always had a great desire to seek audience with and blessings from His Holiness the Dalai Lama.

"Delong Rinpoche left his monastery for Lhasa in August 2001with a Chinese passport. Except for few close monks, no one knew about the trip. Somehow the news had leaked because Lhasa police were already tipped off about Rinpoche's arrival in Lhasa. It is believed that Karze County police force were behind the act.

"In Lhasa, Rinpoche stayed in a hotel with a few of his attendants. A week later, Rinpoche was denied Chinese Visa to travel to India for pilgrimage and was ordered to return to his hometown. No credible explanation was provided for the denial. Rinpoche had to fly back with his attendants to Nyarong.

"The local people were highly disappointed with the whole turn of events. They were saddened by the fact that Rinpoche's desire for an audience with HH the Dalai Lama remained unfulfilled. Though Rinpoche is of Chinese origin, his reverence for HH the Dalai Lama is strong. Chinese authorities fear that once Rinpoche leaves Tibet, he might not return. Moreover, Chinese government never appreciates anyone meeting HH the Dalai Lama whom they consider as an enemy of China,"

recalls Gyurmay.

[ top ]

Political incident at a "patriotic education" session

A 30-year-old Dorjee reached Tibetan Reception Centre in Kathmandu on 15 September 2002. He is a farmer from Gormo Municipality in Amdo Ngaba.

Dorjee reported to TCHRD,

"Chinese authorities have extended 'patriotic education' campaign into the lay community as well. During the yearly meeting that the authorities hold for the local populace, Chinese officials would call upon the masses to imbibe communist ideology and to discard 'splittist' ideas.

"In October 1999, more than 100 Chinese officials including the head of Gorma Municipality (Golmud shi) attended one such meeting. When a break was announced in between the meeting, I stood up to walk forward. The township head directly pointed at me and asked 'what do you want?' I responded 'I want Free Tibet'. I spoke it loud and clear. An elderly Tibetan told me to run but I did not.

"Within few minutes, a dozen armed police and soldiers dashed into the crowd and walked up to me. I always carried a small paper knife in my pocket. I took that out and the police were hesitant to come close to me at first. But I was outnumbered and my knife was snatched away. My arms were twisted behind my back. All of a sudden, I was pulled down to the ground and all police and soldiers began to beat and kick me. From that day onwards, I have hearing problem.

"That evening, I was taken to the local PSB Detention Centre. As beating continued in the detention centre, I vomited blood. I became so sick that I could not eat and move around. My inmates called the police and reported my precarious condition. A doctor who checked me told that I needed immediate medical attention.

"After one month and 15 days's hospitalisation, the doctor still recommended complete bed rest. My family paid all the medical expenses. So, an agreement was reached with the police that my parents would take care of me. However, I had to report to the police station on a regular basis. In that way, I was allowed to return home.

"In 2001, I was having lunch in a restaurant with several other friends. Suddenly, few PSB officers barged into the restaurant and I was whisked away. I was interrogated about my activities and subsequently subjected to minor beatings.

"Then, one day, I was paraded around with several other criminal prisoners. I was detained for 15 days and released. I was told that my movements and activities would be monitored.

"Because of such restrictions, I escaped with my wife and four children to India. I also hope that my children will get better educationn in exile."

[ top ]

Exile Tibetan detained for entry into Tibet

In stark contradiction to Chinese government's claim of welcoming exile Tibetan brethrens into Tibet, TCHRD has received several cases of people being arrested for attempting entry into Tibet. Tseten Dorjee, 28, born in India, faced detention when he recently tried to go to Tibet. Dorjee related to TCHRD,

"I was born to a seven-member family in Kollegal Tibetan Settlement in South India. I worked as a chef in several places in India. I was also at the Indian Army for seven years since 1992. In February 2002, I reached Nepal.

"After a few days in Nepal, I met several newcomers who were returning to Tibet. I took the opportunity to join the group. We walked via Mount Kailash and reached Ngari 'TAP'. We came across seven policemen and they detained us for 18 days in Ngari Detention Centre. Afterwards, we were transferred to a new detention centre in Shigatse, just opposite Tashi Lhunpo Monastery. There were more than 200 Tibetan prisoners who all were arrested for attempted escape from and entry into Tibet.

"I was interrogated mainly about the purpose of my trip and the exile Tibetan government based in North India. I was asked about the main contents of the talks given by the newly elected Prime Minister Samdhong Rinpoche; number of departments in the exile government; number of staff at the Tibetan Reception Centre and their activities. I was also questioned as to how many exile Tibetans schools have been set up. They have lots of photos from exile, mainly of schools and monasteries. I replied that I entered Tibet to meet my relatives, and pilgrimage.

"This new detention centre had a sign board 'Reception Center' (Tib: Nyelenkhang). According to information published in a newspaper, Nyelenkang was reportedly meant to provide accommodation to exile Tibetans who return to Tibet. The rooms have decent facilities including nice and thick cushions and clean toilets. But the inmates have to follow strict rules and regulations such as complete restrictions on singing songs, prayers and outings. We were provided a cup of black tea and a little Tsampa (roasted barley) in the afternoon and mostly uncooked Tibetan noodles in the evening.

"As 'reception centre' was newly constructed, it has a new impressive look. However, it is no different from a regular prison because restrictions are imposed on the inmates' freedom of movement and expression. The name is just a facade.

"During my detention, Taiwanese and Singaporean visitors from Lhasa visited the prison block. During their visit, we got good food but afterwards, the food would be just the same. When people fall sick, they don't get good medical treatment at the detention Centre. The medicine that I received for my lung disease there aggravated my sickness. They had to take me to Shigatse People's Hospital. I was detained for six months and 20 days. During that time, I was forced to work with other inmates in the construction of roads and buildings.

"Since I didn't have a travel permit, I was deported to Nepal via Shigatse and Dram (Tibet-Nepal border). I was not even allowed a pilgrimage. In Dram, the Chinese police facilitated my crossover into the Nepali area.

"I went to Tibet to see the true situation inside Tibet. On our outings for construction works, I saw that rural Tibet is still reeling under high poverty like in areas like Dingri and Shigatse. The so-called development is confined only to the metropolitan cities. I have found that even the roads in the rural areas are rugged compared to the cities. I felt sad to notice such poverty in Tibet. There were many Tibetan beggars as well.

"Once I arrived in Nepal, I feigned madness and the border police let me proceed to Kathmandu. I arrived at the Tibetan Reception Centre in Kathmandu on 23 November 2002."

[ top ]

Escapee's experiences across the border

Twenty-two-year-old Lobsang Sherab reported to TCHRD,

"I was a herder before becoming a monk at 15 years in Sogtsang Monastery. I am originally from Dzoge County, Ngaba 'TAP', Sichuan Province.

"In April 2000, two monks from my monastery, Phegyal and Palden, wrote 'Free Tibet' on the windscreen of a private vehicle parked on the roadside. On that day itself, local police arrested both the monks. Later, Dzoge County Court sentenced the two monks to two years' prison term. Palden was released before the completion of his term but Phegyal passed away at the end of February 2002 after release. It is said that he suffered immense torture in the prison. I don't know the name of the prison. Both the monks are originally from my native place.

"In May 2001, I tried to escape Tibet with a group of five including a road guide. Before we managed to cross Solukhumbu, Chinese patrolling policemen arrested us. It was around midnight. After tying our shoelaces together, the police kicked us around. They hit shoes on our head and said it was symbolic of HH the Dalai Lama giving us blessings. They did all these in an apparent attempt to make a mockery out of our deep faith in HH the Dalai Lama. Our religious sentiments were deeply hurt by their callous behaviours.

"The following day, we were detained for a night in Tingri Detention Centre in Shigatse 'TAP'. We were later transferred to Nyari Prison (or Shigatse PSB Detention Centre) where we were detained for four months. There were five blocks in the prison and my group was put in block four. There were about 170 people in the block, most of whom were Tibetans returning from India. I saw Tenpa Dhargyal and Thinlay from Amdo Golog. They were detained because they had brought eight Tibetan national flags and other political documents from India. The two were interrogated for 15 days and they suffered tremendous beatings.

"In September 2001, 69 of us from Dzoge County were sent back to our place in a truck. There, we were detained for ten more days. After paying a fine of yuan 3,500 to the county police, I was released.

"Soon after we were in Dzoge County, three Sogtsang Monastery monks pasted posters in Thango Township area. The posters called for 'unity amongst the Tibetans, and that the Tibetans should use Tibetan language and preserve Tibetan culture.' The three involved in the poster-pasting incident are Choephel, Wangden and Yibning. Dzoge police officers immediately arrested the three monks. Choephel, believed to be the instigator of the incident, was sentenced to two years' imprisonment while the other two were fined 4000 yuan each.

"I went with my group of five to Lhasa again in February 2002. We stayed in a hotel nearby Lhasa called Mentzekham. The Chinese police arrested us for no reason. They said we looked like murderers, and that we appeared to have plans to escape to exile. After being detained for five days, we were released. The rest of my companions were returned to Dzoge and I remained in Drepung Monastery in Lhasa. In September 2002, I escaped again with 28 others and reached Tibetan Reception Centre in Kathmandu on 30 September 2002."

[ top ]

A prisoner flees from Drapchi Prison hospital

Karma Dawa alias Kadar fled from a hospital located near Drapchi Prison where he was recuperating after undergoing a major operation. He was serving a total sentence of 21 years.

Formerly booked under criminal offences of alleged robbery and gun pilfering from a police officer, Lhasa Intermediate Court sentenced Kadar to 13 years' term in Drapchi Prison. Kadar along with other co-prisoner Karma Sonam initiated the May 1998 Drapchi Prison protests during which they raised pro-independence slogans and threw leaflets into the air. This daring act within the prison compound earned them sentence extension of eight and nine years respectively.

TCHRD held four interview sessions with Kadar. TCHRD produced below the translated version of his personal testimony written in Tibetan language:

"I am originally from Sershul County (Ch: shiqu xian). In 1994, I came to Lhasa with my companion Tsering Norbu for pilgrimage and business. Within four days, seven policemen arrested us near Ramochi Monastery and detained us in a police headquarter. We were accused of robbing people and stealing gun from a police officer. Both of us were beaten very badly.

"After one week, we were transferred to Gutsa Detention Centre where I was detained for a year and eight months. During interrogations, I was shocked with electric cattle prod and threatened with further assault to extort confession. The whole time I was detained, I did not confess to the charges.

"Finally, I was sentenced to 13 years' prison term after three court trials. I repeatedly stated my innocence and demanded the court to produce either evidence or witness of my alleged crimes. Upon being sentenced, I requested an appeal against the sentence. The court officials told me that I would have to complete my sentence before I was allowed to appeal.

"In 1996, I was shifted to Unit 6 of Drapchi Prison. I recounted my story to a Tibetan official in the prison who encouraged me to appeal. Therefore, I sent two appeals to Lhasa Intermediate People's Court. In the appeal letter, I wrote my experiences of being falsely charged, of my trial and innocence.

"Three months later, two Lhasa Intermediate Court officials arrived at Drapchi to meet me. Dekyi, a Tibetan woman official asked me why I wrote the appeal letter and said it was a useless exercise. She advised me against pursuing an appeal as that might possibly lead to sentence extension. I restated to the officials about my innocence and demanded that they provide proof of my crimes. The officials noted down all my comments but nothing happened thereafter.

"For three years, I worked in the sewing room of Drapchi. I used to secretly listen to (Tibetan broadcast of) Voice of America and Radio Free Asia. I became aware of the conditions of Tibetan political prisoners. During visits of the foreign delegations, the food in Drapchi would improve; otherwise the food was generally inadequate to meet the health needs of the prison inmates. During such visits, most of the Tibetan political prisoners were shifted to their cells to show that there were not many political prisoners.

"In the quiets of the prison cell, I would reflect on the sad tragedy of the Tibetan situation. Hence, I felt increasingly obliged to protest the conditions under which the Tibetans suffer under Communist China in general and the horrific conditions of political prisoners in particular. I held discussion with Karma Sonam, another prisoner, and we decided to protest whenever an appropriate opportunity presented itself; either a visit from a foreign delegation or on an important anniversary or any large public meeting. So, Sonam and I wrote 'Free Tibet' and 'Long Live His Holiness the Dalai Lama' on small sheets and had 15 each.

"On 1 May 1998, the prison authorities planned to celebrate the International Labour Day which was to have a flag-raising ceremony, and demonstration of military drills by the inmates. All the prisoners, both criminal and political, were lined up for the occasion. Just before the flag was raised, Sonam and I stepped forward and shouted 'Free Tibet' and distributed leaflets. Other prisoners promptly joined in and shouted 'Free Tibet'. This caused total chaos for about twenty minutes in the prison compound. The Chinese army and police immediately responded by converging on the prisoners. Many prisoners were beaten and suffered serious injuries. This protest resulted in the consequent death of eight political prisoners and sentence extension of 27 political prisoners.

"I was badly beaten and placed in solitary confinement for three months and 28 days with hands cuffed and feet manacled. I was interrogated on a monthly basis and two prisoners were assigned to monitor and report on all my activities. After this period, I was again taken to court to be re-sentenced. I received sentence extension of eight years and Karma Sonam got nine years' sentence. I again used the opportunity to protest my innocence and to denounce the unjust court procedures.

"At this time, the court agreed to investigate my previous trial. However, nothing came of it and I did not hear of any results of the investigations. During both trials, I was denied access to legal representation and only Karma Sonam, myself and Chinese court officials were present. Both of us were placed in Unit One of Drapchi Prison.

"I began to experience serious health problems, however, prison officials refused to believe that I was unwell and my health began to deteriorate. After repeated pleas for medical check-up, I was finally taken to Lhasa Military Hospital sometime in July 1999. During all this time, both my feet and wrists were chained. A doctor recommended that I required operation.

"I was told to sign a document claiming responsibility for my death in the event of a failed operation. A prison official asked me if I had any wish to be fulfilled before the operation. I requested them to let my mother visit me in the hospital but this was denied. I then asked them to remove the chains from my body but this too was denied. I was chained even while the operation was being performed.

"After one month in the hospital, my condition began to improve. I once again requested for the chains to be removed but to no avail. Two army guards guarded all the political prisoners from Drapchi in the hospital. One day they decided that all the prisoners should wash and hence we were taken to the courtyard. I declined to go as I found it difficult to walk. Out of sympathy, the guards removed my chains. Soon, new guards arrived who did not insist on the chains to be put on. So, I hid the chains under the bed and was free to move about. The guards did not seem to know that I should be chained. So, I escaped this painful experience.

"After three days on 6 August 1999, I saw an opportunity to escape. At about one o'clock in the afternoon, I told the guards that I wanted to go to the bathroom. I wore my plain clothes inside my prisoner's uniform. The guards were watching television and did not pay much attention to me. When I saw the guards completely engrossed with a TV programme, I quietly slipped out of the bathroom and ran away.

"I ran for three days before I began to slow down to walk. I went to my uncle's place and stayed there for a month. I managed to escape before the police could arrive to arrest me. My uncle and his daughter faced intimidation by the police for not reporting about me immediately. I was in hiding for many months.

"In 2002, I managed to escape all the way to Tibetan Reception Centre in Nepal. I escaped mainly to avoid re-arrest and to serve as a voice for other imprisoned Tibetan political prisoners still languishing in Chinese jails."

[ top ]

TCHRD briefs EU First Secretary in India

Mr. Francois Massouli, EU's First Secretary (Pol) in India was in Dharamsala for a two-day visit from 29 November to 1 December 2002.

During his short visit to TCHRD, the Executive Director and staff members briefed him on the current human rights situation in Tibet.

The First Secretary was also acquainted with the plight of Tibetans languishing in the Nepali Prison. TCHRD raised the issue of right to self-determination to be included in the China-EU dialogue on human rights.

[ top ]

Orientation to TCHRD staff on refugee law

Mr. Deepak Kumar Thakur, a prominent Delhi based lawyer and refugee law expert, gave orientation to TCHRD staff members on refugee law and refugee rights on 30 November 2002.

The staff members raised many pertinent questions concerning the Indian laws guaranteeing refugee rights and freedom of movement.