Tibetan Centre for Human Rights and Democracy

Human Rights Update and Archives

November 1999

Chinese police open fire on 3,000 peaceful protestors  [ read ]
Arrests of three monks  [ read ]
Sinocisation of school syllabus  [ read ]
Returning Tibetan faces detention  [ read ]
Testimony of a juvenile political prisoner  [ read ]
The cost of resistance  [ read ]
Assault on religion: Patriotic re-education in monasteries  [ read ]
Ngawang Dhipsel in critical health  [ read ]

Chinese police open fire on 3,000 peaceful protestors

On October 31, 1999, officers of the Karze County Public Security Bureau (PSB) opened fire on approximately 3,000 Tibetan protestors in Karze County in Sichuan Province, Karze "Tibetan Autonomous Prefecture" (TAP). The protestors were demanding the immediate release of three Tibetans from Karze County who were detained on grounds of suspicion for their involvement in political activities in October of 1999. The protest lasted for 30 minutes in front of the Karze County People's Government and Karze Detention Centre. The protest was held six days after the arrest of the three Tibetans.

Information from Tibet has indicated that the police opened fire at the demonstrators and threw tear gas shells to disperse the crowd. PSB officers arrested approximately 30 protestors on the day of the protest. Local hospitals were instructed not to attend to any of the injured people. Furthermore, PAP forces were stationed at various hospitals to ensure compliance. All of the major religious institutions in Karze County were under tight survelliance.

At least 80 Tibetans were reported to have been arrested in connection with the protest, of which names of only five are available. Sonam Yeshi, Pema Phuntsok, Loga, Wangdak and Wangdue are all detained in Karze Detention Centre. The inmates were reportedly held in incommunicado detention. Although the exact figure is not available at this time, recent reports indicate that some of the protestors were released and others will will be released after paying a fine.

Several incidents of political unrest were reported in Karze this year. Chinese authorities have reportedly deployed large number of troops in Karze County following incidents of resistance to Chinese policies. On July 20, 1999, PSB officials arrested 11 monks from Karze Dhargye Monastery after discovering pro-independence slogans on the walls of the monastery. The monks were charged with inscribing "Tibet is independent" with red paint on the gates and walls of the monastery. Their identities and whereabouts are unknown.

[ top ]

Arrests of three monks

A respected and learned monk of Karze Dhargye Monastery, Sonam Phuntsok, along with two other monks, Sonam Choephel and Agya Tsering were arrested on October 24, 1999 by officials of the Karze County PSB. Sources within Tibet report that Chinese authorities have detained Sonam Phuntsok in Datsedo County in Karze "TAP". Sonam was suspected of having "clandestine contacts" with the Tibetan government-in-exile. Agya and Sonam Choephel are currently held in Karze Detention Centre.

Sources indicate that Sonam Phuntsok's popularity was an apparent threat to the Chinese authority. They were reportedly aware that his arrest would create resentment among the Tibetan people. The authorities had stationed approximately 20,000 PSB and People's Armed Police (PAP) officers in the area prior to the arrest of the three monks.

Sonam Phuntsok is well-known figure and Tibetans in the region regard him as a great Buddhist practitioner and scholar. He is well known for teaching Tibetan literature to young monks. He had also recorded the historical description of 13 monasteries in Karze "TAP" and two of his books have been published.

Prior to his arrest, Sonam Phuntsok had initiated a long-life prayer offering for the Dalai Lama. In an address he made around that time, he praised the Dalai Lama and advised the people to follow his preaching. Aware of the consequences for such an action, he informed the public that he "did not regret anything".

Sonam Phuntsok was born in 1951 in Karze County, Kham Province (Sichuan). Agya Tsering alias "Agyong", 47 years-old was first arrested in February 1990 for allegedly printing and distributing leaflets calling for Tibetan independence. In 1990, he put up posters on the gates of various government buildings in Karze as well as in prominent locations in Odoling City in Qinghai Province. He was detained in Yushu "TAP", Amdo (Chinese: Qinghai Province). He was remanded to 18 months of "re-education through labour" without trial.

Born in Jurenno Village in Diwo Township, Karze County, he studied in Magtsuk School (People's School) in Karze for five years and later joined Dargye Monastery. Sonam Choephel is reportedly the assistant to Sonam Phuntsok. No other details of Sonam are available.Due to the increased security in Karze, efforts to obtain precise details concerning the identities and place of detention of those arrested has been limited.

[ top ]

Sinocisation of school syllabus

Nyima is a 15 year-old student from Sichuan Province in Karze "TAP", Bathang County. His parents are farmers and there are five members in his family. He attended a mang-tsuk school called "mi mang lob chung"in his county where there were approximately five hundred students. There were three other primary schools in the district. Nyima went to the school from the age of seven and completed his education in 1998. There were both Chinese and Tibetan students in his school. The head of the school was Chinese and there were eighty teachers of whom fifty were Chinese while thrity were Tibetan.

All the Chinese teachers taught in Chinese and the text books were also in Chinese which Nyima found hard to follow. One of the rules stated that Tibetan students were not allowed to speak Tibetan during a Chinese class and he was once beaten up for having spoken in Tibetan in a Chinese class. There was a marked contrast in the kind of teaching for Tibetan and Chinese students. In the Tibetan class the students were only taught to read and write, while in the Chinese class there were lessons on history of the Chinese state. There were never any lessons about the culture, religion or history of Tibet.

Most of the manual work like cleaning was done by Tibetan students while the Chinese students were exempted from such duties. Nyima finally fled Tibet on October 15, 1999 and 3, 1999.

[ top ]

Returning Tibetan faces detention

Yonten Tharchin, 27 years old, was detained for six months in Tsolho Prison after he was found to have brought some cassettes from India to Tibet. Tharchin was returning to Tibet after spending five years in India.

In January 1996, the Chinese army caught Tharchin at Dram near the Tibetan border, when he was found entering without valid documents. He was detained in Dram for 17 days along with seven members of his group. During his detention he was forced to wash clothes and cut firewood for the army. Tharchin was detained successively in various places: Nyelam for three days, Shigatse for 50 days, Golmud for a day, and finally transferred to Tsolho Prison.

While in Tsolho Prison, he was found to possess audio cassettes with speeches of the Dalai Lama. As a consequence he was tortured and forced to stand facing the wall with his hand stretched upwards, while his arm pit hair was removed. He was interrogated on the administrations of the exiled Tibetan government

In April of 1996, Tharchin was issued an indictment paper that said he would be sentenced to three years imprisonment. However, one of his relatives helped to get him released after bribing 6000 yuan (US $ 700) to officials. Even after his release, he was constantly kept under surveillance.

In June 1999, a relative who worked in the government informed him that he needed to remove any thing in his home which might cause for further trouble, since Chinese officials would raid his house soon. Unable to bear the situation, he again fled his hometown in Tibet for India, and reached Dharamsala on October 10, 1999.

Tharchin is from Baku Town in Thurde County, Qinghai province. He joined a village school at the age of seven and studied there until he joined a monastery at the age of 13. Tharchin had earlier visited India at the age of 19, and stayed for five years.

[ top ]

Testimony of a juvenile political prisoner

Norzin Wangmo, 22 years old, is a former Shugseb nun who spent five years in Drapchi Prison when she was 16 years old. Originally from Ju Village in Gentsey Township in Gongkar County, Lhoka Region, Norzin reached Dharamsala, India on November 27, 1999. Norzin's parents are farmers and she has 10 siblings. She joined Shugseb Nunnery in 1989 at the age of 12.

In the morning of December 9, 1993, Norzin and seven other nuns of Shugseb Nunnery demonstrated in front of the Central Cathedral in Lhasa Barkhor. The nuns demonstrated for approximately 15 minutes, after which they were arrested by Barkhor Security Personnel and policemen patrolling on the "shasar sur" lane of the Barkhor. The nuns continued to shout independence slogans even as they were being arrested. Many people witnessed the arrest of the nuns.The police put them in a van and beat all the nuns severely with cords made of rubber. Norzin was hit hard on her right eye, resulting in severe impairment of her vision which still effects her. The nuns were taken to Gutsa Detention Centre where they were kept separately and interrogated individually. They were detained in Gutsa for around 11 months where they were interrogated at least 20 times.

During this detention, none of the nuns were allowed to receive visitors. Their parents and the relatives who came to see them were unable to do so. The nuns did not receive the food and clothes which their parents or relatives had brought. They were kept by the prison guards who issued fake receipt to the senders or visitors. At the time of interrogation, the nuns were asked various questions regarding the demonstration: how they organised it and with whose assistance. The nuns answered that "they came on their own to demonstrate" and that "there was no outside force responsible". These answers did not seem to satisfy the officers because the nuns were severely beaten again. Norzin was 16 at that time but she suffered nonetheless. She was beaten with a wooden plank and given shock treatments with an electric baton.

After eight months of detention and interrogation, the nuns were tried in the "Tibet Autonomous Region" (TAR) Intermediate People's Court on September 10, 1994. Norzin and the eight nuns were charged with propagating "counter-revolutionary" activities under article 102 of the Criminal Procedure Law of the People's Republic of China. Rinzin Tsondue and Jampa Choekyi were charged as the primary leaders responsible for "spearheading" the demonstration. The nuns" plea of innocence was ignored and they were sentenced to six years" imprisonment and two years deprivation of political rights on September 13, 1994. On September 17, 1994, they were finally transferred to Drapchi Prison. Norzin Wangmo (16), Lodoe Pema (24), Namgyal Choedon (22), Sherab Dolma (19), Choenyi Dolma (17) and Norbu Yangchen (17) were sentenced to five years" imprisonment and two years deprivation of political rights. All six were released on December 8, 1998.

In Drapchi, Norzin was confined in the 3rd Unit along with the rest of the nuns. Everyday, the nuns were assigned to clean, prune and make yarn out of four sang (about 200 grams) of wool. This was a quota fixed by prison authorities, which the nuns had to accomplish within a day. After March 1996, the eight nuns were separated from the older prisoners. The 3rd Unit was divided into two sections as the Old and the New 3rd Unit. Norzin and the eight nuns were kept in the old 3rd unit. Norzin reported that the separation made it almost impossible for them to even see let alone establish any contact with the senior political prisoners.

When the eight nuns first arrived in Drapchi Prison, the prison authorities issued them cotton quilts which were immediately taken away by their unit leader. During the winter of 1996, trouble arose when prison authorities ordered the nuns to clean their unit. The nuns refused and instead demanded that their new quilts be returned to them. They were reprimanded and serious punishemnts were imposed. Norzin in particular was confined in a solitary cell for 45 days and was given only one meal a day.

On May 4, 1998, non-political prisoners and political prisoners of the New 5th and the 3rd Unit were assembled and ordered to participate in official celebrations which inclded hoisting of the Chinese Flag and singing the Chinese national anthem. These prisoners started protesting whereupon they were beaten by the prison authorities and the PAP. On seeing this from their prison windows , the female prisoners of 3rd Unit (old) started shouting at the authorities pleading with them not to beat the other prisoners. In the process the prison windows were broken.

As a result PAP and Prison authorities stormed into their prison cell, made them stand up facing the wall and started beating them.They hit them with their belt buckles. Eventually all the prisoners had head injuries and were bleeding heavily. Ngawang Sangdrol who is serving 21 years was bedridden for two days. The beatings continued despite repeated pleas from the women, and it resulted in cases of broken limbs.

Since the protest, the prisoners have been confined to their cells for the entire day and have not been alowed out for any prision activities. They even have to urinate in a container provided to them in their cell which is cleaned only once a day.Even the extent of injuries suffered by a prisoner is unknown to anyone other than her cellmate since they are not allowed to go out and no one is allowed to see them.

Norzin was released on December 8, 1998. She didn"t know how many prisoners were in her "unit" as she was confined all day in her cell until her release. She reported that since May, 1998 she felt terrible suffocation in her cell and after the protest there were far more severe restrictions than before. Norzin escaped from Lhasa on October 25, 1999.

[ top ]

The cost of resistance

Lobsang Samten (lay name: Phurbu) 23, a former monk of Sera Monastery in Lhasa, arrived in Dharamsala, India, on November 15, 1999. His parents have a small business and work in Lhasa. He has two brothers who are monks, also of Sera Monastery and two sisters. Lobsang attended primary school for three years from the age of seven. He joined the monastery in 1985 and stayed there until 1996. He studied dialectics and English while staying in the monastery.

While he was in Sera Monastery, a 160 member "work team" first came in May-June of 1996. They distributed four documents for the monks to study and conducted "re-education" sessions. They collected all the pictures of the Dalai Lama in the monastery and banned its display. They forbade the monks from engaging in any religious activities in the monastery. On June 12, 1996 a monk named Gyaltsen Thokmey (27) pasted a poster inside the monastery hall calling on the monks to boycott and protest against any type of gatherings organised by "work team" members. He was arrested on September 15, 1996 for this incident and sentenced to six years" imprisonment in Drapchi Prison. He is from Nyemo County.

The monks discontinued the activities of the monastery until June 15, 1996. On June 16, 1996 the "work team" members attempted to force a few young monks and their teachers to perform the normal monastery rituals. This was resisted by the monks who continued to boycott the gatherings. The "re-education" then became even more organised when the "work team" assigned 10 officials for every hostel of the monastery and started giving instructions. The "work teams" then required monks to denounce the Dalai Lama and oppose "splittists". The monks were divided into small groups of 15 and asked to express their opinions on "splittisms". The "work team" members were mostly high officials of the "TAR" government.

Lobsang vehemently resisted the instructions of the "work team" members. He refused to denounce the Dalai Lama and oppose "splittism". He assertively expressed that Tibet was a free nation as it has its own history, culture and money. He was later accused of "disrespecting the law of the nation" and "siding with splittists". That same night on September 27, 1996, five PSB officers came to his room arrested him and searched his room. He was handcuffed and taken to Sangyip Detention Centre where he was interrogated regarding his background and family. At the time of his arrest, other monks were also arrested. They were Tashi Pelthar (25) of Meldo Gongkar County, Norbu (29) of Lhoka Yamdrok County and Bhu-chung (34) of Chamdo Teng-chen County. They were all later remanded to three years of "re-education through labour" and released on September 24, 1999.

Lobsang was later taken to Seitru Detention Centre where he was detained for five months. He was interrogated there at least 15 times and confined to a solitary cell for three months. During interrogation, he was forced to stand and kneel on a chair for approximately two hours. He was given shock treatments with an electric prod at the time of interrogation when he refused or disobeyed the interrogators. Many times he fell unconscious while being tortured.

On February 22, 1997 he was transferred to Gutsa Detention Centre where he was held for another two months. He was not allowed to meet any of his relatives or his parents. When he was in Gutsa, he was informed of his remand to three years "re-education through labor" without any trial or court proceedings. On April 22, 1997, he was transferred to Toelung Trisam Prison. While in Trisam Prison, he was made to do strenous work on a vegetable farm for six hours every day. There were approximately 40 political prisoners in Trisam when he arrived and all of them were assigned separate duties. Lobsang was once beaten severely by a prison guard for violating a prison rule while working. In addition, he was confined to a solitary cell for seven days provided with only water.

Lobsang was released on September 24, 1999 after the completion of his three years in prison. When he was released, there were approximately 11 political prisoners remaining in the prison. The oldest political prisoner in Trisam is Kushab Dawa (65) of Lhasa Tse-mon Ling who is serving a three year sentence. He will be released in July-August of 2001. Lobsang stayed for two months in Lhasa and reached Nepal on November 15, 1999.

[ top ]

Assault on religion: Patriotic re-education in monasteries

Kharchu Monastery:

Between July and August of 1996, a four member work-team from Lhoka Prefecture conducted a "patriotic re-education" campaign in Kharchu Monastery in Lhoka Region, Lhodrag County, "TAR". The "work-team" remained at the monastery for three months. During this period, religious activity at the monastery was severely curtailed. All 17 monks at the monastery were given "re-education" materials and required to study them for three hours every morning, and hold discussions on the materials in the afternoons. The "re-education" consisted of four primary subjects: How Tibet is a part of China, Opposing "splittist" activities, The history of Tibet and Legal studies. After the monks had studied the materials for one and a half months, they were a given an exam. Monks who did not answer the questions according to the authorities wishes were required to re-take the exam after an additional month and a half of study. The monks were instructed to oppose the Dalai Lama and "splittist" activities. All photos of the Dalai Lama were removed. The work-team appointed a new Democratic Management Committee (DMC) and new regulations were established overseeing management of the monastery.

Approximately one month after the work-team left Kharchu Monastery, Lama Namkhai Nyingpo, a monk from Bhutan came to the monastery to perform teachings. During his stay at the monastery, his photo was displayed. After his departure, his photos were removed and banned by Lhodrag County officials. Religious scriptures he had distributed were confiscated.

Dechen Monastery:

Lobsang Tashi is a former monk from Dechen Monastery who was expelled from his monastery by "patriotic re-education" "work-team" members in November of 1998. He is originally from Taglung Village, Lhakhang Thang Township in Trika County, Tsolho Tibetan Autonomous Prefecture, Amdo (Chinese: Qinghai Province). He arrived in exile in India in November of 1999.

Lobsang reports that in September of 1998, a three-member work-team from Trika County came to Dechen Monastery to conduct a "patriotic re-education" campaign. Approximately 60 monks from the monastery attended the sessions, with the other monks excusing themselves, either complaining of illness or going on religious pilgrimage. The monks were forced to study political documents related to the history of Tibet, the Dalai Lama and the Panchen Lama. The monks were made to denounce the Dalai Lama, oppose "splittism", and accept the Chinese appointed Panchen Lama. The monks were given a questionnaire to fill out regarding the aforementioned items. Many monks resisted, particularly regarding questions related to the Dalai Lama and the Panchen Lama. The work-team left the monastery after five days.

In November of 1998, the work-team returned to the monastery, this time with members of the Public Security Bureau. All monks were required to attend the ìre-educationî sessions. The same questionnaire was distributed to the monks. Initially, many of the monks refused to comply with the demands of the "work-team" members. After some time, except for ten monks, the rest succeeded to the demands of the work-team. The ten monks (including Lobsang Tashi) were immediately expelled and were forbidden from joining any other religious institution. All photos of the Dalai Lama were banned and removed. The "work-team" then set age parameters for the monastery. All monks over 50 or under 18 years of age were expelled. After four days, the "work-team" left the monastery. Lobsang Tashi returned to his village, though he continued to study religious text and wear his monastic robes. The work-team returned to the monastery a third time in May of 1999 to conduct further "re-education". The "work-team" sent a message to Lobsang Tashi's home that he must discontinue his studies and remove his robes. He was additionally summoned to a meeting with the "work-team". Fearing reprisals or further trouble, he escaped to India.

Awam Monastery:

Samten Tsering was a 19 year-old monk of Awam Monastery, which is located in Thang-gya Shang of Meldo Gongkar County. His parents were farmers, and he had enrolled in mangtsuk' school from the age of 9 to 10 where he studied Tibetan. At the age of 11, he joined Awam Monastery. Presently, this monastery has around 12 monks. Before 1959, there were around 500 monks in this monastery.

The monastery was one of those which had been completely destroyed during the Cultural Revolution. Since 1982, with monetary assistance and manual help of the local Tibetans there had been renovation work carried out in Awam monastery by a monk named Namgyal la.

In May-June of 1997 a "work team" of approximately ten members came to the monastery. They stayed for about four months and conducted "re-education" sessions. The monks were ordered to denounce the Dalai Lama but refused to do so. As a result the duration of the "re-education" was raised from three months to four in an attempt to pursuade the monks to accede to the demands of the "work team".

In the beginning of June, the "work team" announced that they would return in January-February of 1997. This announcement was also coupled with threats stating that monks who attempted to evade the "re-education" would be dealt with personally and "re-educated" forcibly. They also threatened to prosecute such "rebels" with the charge of "protesting against the nation", which could earn them three to four years in labour prisons.

In July-August of 1999, the Bhar Monastery invited Geshe Lobsang Sherab for the second time to Taktse County to give religious discourses to the monks of three different monasteries. At that time, around 60 monks gathered in Bhar Monastery to receive religious discourses from Geshe Lobsang Sherab. On the third day of religious discourse in Bhar Monastery, the Taktse County PSB came to the monastery and ordered the monks to stop giving or receiving religious teachings. The PSB then accused Geshe Lobsang Sherab of misleading the masses through his teachings. They threatened to arrest people if the teachings was not stopped immediately.

On August 6, 1999, the religious sermon in Bhar Monastery was forcibly interrupted by approximately 20 PSB officials of the Taktse County. The monks of Awam Monastery and Phak-mo Monastery were sent back to their respective monasteries. Geshe Lobsang Sherab was interrogated about his "aim" and "reasons" for giving religious discourses. He was immediately ordered to return to Lhasa the following day.

At that time, approximately 400 people, including monks present for the religious sermon protested against the PSB officers" interference. Geshe Lobsang Sherab advised them to calm down, in order to avoid tension with the PSB. The PSB officers later individually interrogated the people about the contents of the preaching.

Since then, the three monasteries have been regularly inspected by the County Authorities. An order was issued on August 23, 1999 that, "no monks from any monasteries were allowed to practice religion outside of their monastery" and "no monk is allowed to receive religious discourses from any lama in any villages of Taktse County"

The County authorities issued an order which prohibited the monks from attending or performing any prayer services in private homes in villages. They announced that "the sermon from August 5-6, 1999 was organised against the law and security of the nation and whoever attended it had violated the law". Samten escaped from his monastery and reached Lhasa on September 30, 1999. He left Lhasa and reached Nepal on November 14, 1999.

Dongthok Monastery:

Lobsang Namkha is a 25 year-old monk of Dong-thok Monastery in Kandze "TAP", Karze County, Karok Shang. His Parents are farmers. Lobsang went to school from the age of seven to ten after which he started looking after his family's livestock. At the age of 15, he became a monk of Dong-thok Monastery.

Dong-thok Monastery was one of the monasteries which had been completely destroyed during the Cultural Revolution. After 1983, this monastery was reconstructed with the help of local Tibetans. When Lobsang joined this monastery, there was around 10 monks but at present there are around 50 monks in the monastery.

In 1997 the "work team" came to the monastery for the first time after which they visited the monastery twice a month. The "work team" organised meetings in the monastery and instructed the monks to oppose "splittists" and to denounce the Dalai Lama. There were usually five to seven official members of the "work team". All pictures of the Dalai Lama were banned in the monastery. The monks were also forced to study books given to them by the "work team" during the meetings. In May-June of 1998, a mass meeting was organised in Karok Township and around 300 monks and nuns from five different monasteries and nunneries of the Kandze County were called. During the mass "meeting", the monks and nuns were instructed to write "opposition letters" and sign "pledges" against the Dalai Lama.

The "work team" warned them that any disobedience or protest would be met with punishment as well as expulsion. They would also be labelled as being a "political suspect" which implied that they would be constantly harassed even after their expulsion. It was also announced that no new monks would be admitted in any monastery or nunnery of the Karze "TAP" above the limitation set by the "work team" members.

As a result of the interferences in the religious workings of the monastery, Lobsang Namkha decided to leave the monastery in October-November of 1999 and went to Lhasa. He then escaped to Nepal through the Nepal border after paying 900 yuan to a guide. He reached Nepal on November 30, 1999.

[ top ]

Ngawang Dhipsel in critical health

Ngawang Dhipsel (lay name: Penpa) is 30 years old from Phenpo Lhundrup County, Lhasa City. Ngawang studied for four years in a Mangtsuk School(school established by local people) after which he stayed home to help his parents on the farm.

In 1986 he joined Drepung Monastery. On May 13, 1992, Ngawang along with ten other monks from Drepung staged a peaceful demonstration demanding ìFreedom for Tibetî in the Barkhor area in Lhasa City. All of the monks were immediately arrested by Public Security Bureau (PSB) officers.

According to confirmed reports, at the time of arrest the monks were severely beaten. They were initially detained in Gutsa Detention Centre and were beaten during interrogation. In September of 1992, the Lhasa Intermediate People's Court sentenced Ngawang Dhipsel to four years" imprisonment with two years deprivation of political rights. The other monks were given sentences ranging from two to ten years. All the monks were transferred at the end of the year to Drapchi Prison in Lhasa.

1992 was a labourious year in Drapchi. The inmates had to engage in difficult tasks such as contsruction, growing vegetable (green house) and accumulating manure. Around May of 1993, Ngawang and his cellmates were required to construct a canal. The inmates were given a specific period of time to complete the project. Prisoners were required to work late in the evenings and early in the mornings to complete the project. Ngawang Dhipsel was required to dig a foundation for a wall. Due to the harsh conditions, Ngawang Dhipsel fell unconscious. He was taken to the his room but was denied medical treatment. Componding his condition, Dhipsel suffered from hypertension and epilepsy but continued to serve his prison term.

On May 12, 1996 Ngawang Dhipsel was released after four years" imprisonment. He was not allowed to re-join his or any other monastery.

After his release he was subjected to constant surveillance and his activities were closely monitored by the PSB. Unable to withstand this harassment, he attempted to escape to India in November of 1997.

When he reached near the Tibet - Nepal border (Gyala Pass), he encountered heavy snow. Without adequate food and clothing, he was forced to return to Lhasa.

On December 22, 1997, after one month in Lhasa, he was arrested by the PSB under suspicion of "political activities" from Zehtoe Restaurant (a well-known restaurant in Lhasa). He was taken to Lhoka Bureau in Lhasa and interrogated for several hours. Later that evening he was taken to Sietru Detention Centre in Lhasa. The following day he was taken to Tsethang Detention Centre and interrogated repeatedly. In both the detention centres, he suffered brutal beatings at the hands of the Lhoka PSB officers. He was denied visits from his parents throughout his time of detainment.

In January 1998, the Lhoka PSB remanded him to three years of "re-education through labour". He was charged with "attempting to flee Tibet" and "suspicion of engaging in political activities". In May of 1998 he was transferred to Trisam "re-education through labour camp". Ngawang Dhipsel is currently in Trisam and his health is reportedly extremely poor.

In Trisam Prison, prisoners are forced to work in construction of buildings and in the winter, prisoners have to do military drills. In November of 1998, Dhipsel was injured while performing prison exercises but was denied medical treatment.

In April of 1999, he had a severe epileptic attack and was taken to Trisam Prison Hospital. However, he is reported to have not received adequate treatment and his health further deteriorated. There are grave concerns for his health and safety.