Tibetan Centre for Human Rights and Democracy

Human Rights Update and Archives

15 May 1999

Drepung monk re-arrested  [ read ]
Tortured for UN letter  [ read ]
Religious crackdown in Kirti Monastery  [ read ]
Profile: 15 years for Gaden monk  [ read ]
Expulsion of monks in Drayab Monastery  [ read ]
Crackdown at Drupde Monastery  [ read ]

Drepung monk re-arrested

Ngawang Samphel A Tibetan monk from Drepung Monastery in Lhasa, Ngawang Samphel (33), was arrested in early April 1999 on suspicion of political acts. His present whereabouts are unknown. This is the second time that Ngawang has been arrested. He was previously detained in Gutsa Detention Centre for taking part in a demonstration, on September 27, 1988.

On September 27, 1988, Ngawang Samphel and five other Drepung monks, Ngawang Zegen (22), Ngawang Chemey (30), Ngawang Thosam (28), Jamphel Wangchuk (28) and Jamphel Sherab (31), staged a peaceful demonstration in the Barkhor in Lhasa, shouting slogans that called for Tibetan independence. Officers of the People's Armed Police (PAP) and Public Security Bureau (PSB) immediately arrested the monks. They were taken to Gutsa Detention Centre, located to the east of Lhasa. While in detention, all six monks were subjected to severe torture. As a result of the torture, Ngawang"s friend, Ngawang Zegen from Toelung County, died in 1989 approximately one month after his release.

In recent years, despite the strict Chinese policy of religious and patriotic re-education, Tibetan independence posters continue to be seen in Drepung Monastery. The Chinese re-education ìwork-teamsî have recently imposed stringent restrictions on all activities in the monastery. In order to check the growing dissent among the monks, PSB officers are now permanently stationed at the monastery.

In early April 1999, these officers raided Ngawang Samphel's room. Nothing was found that could have implicated him in any political activity. Nonetheless, Ngawang was subsequently arrested on the ground of suspicion of political acts. Since his arrest, no information has been available regarding his well-being or whereabouts. The Tibetan Centre for Human Rights and Democracy is concerned about the fate of Ngawang Samphel, particularly as this is the second time he has been arrested for political acts. Unless immediate intervention and action is taken on his behalf, the Centre fears that his life will be in danger.

Ngawang Samphel is from Phenpo Lhundrup County, ìTARî. He joined Drepung Monastery in 1983, at the age of 16. He was imprisoned from September 27, 1988 and was released after nine months detention. After his release, Ngawang returned to Drepung monastery where he remained until he was rearrested in April 1999.

[ top ]

Tortured for UN letter

Tibetan political prisoner Ngawang Kyonmey suffered severe beatings and maltreatment from prison officers in Gutsa Detention Centre, according to information received from a Tibetan refugee in March 1999. Ngawang was arrested in early September 1998 on suspicion of conspiring to hand a letter to Mrs Mary Robinson, the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights, who visited Tibet in October 1998.

In September 1998, Chinese officials visited Drepung Monastery, Lhasa, in response to information that posters calling for Tibetan independence had been pasted on the walls of the monastery. The officials searched the rooms of the monks and discovered a Tibetan national flag, picture of His Holiness the Dalai Lama and a letter addressed to the High Commissioner, Mrs Mary Robinson, in Ngawang Kyonmey's room. He was immediately arrested and taken to Gutsa Detention Centre where he reportedly continues to be held, although the charges against him have not been finalised.

The Tibetan Centre for Human Rights and Democracy received reports that Ngawang"s body reveals the distinct marks of severe beatings, which evidently took place during interrogation by prison officials who used violence and torture to obtain names of other Tibetans involved in the preparation of the letter.

Ngawang is now 28 years old and was originally from Toelung Dechen County. Ngawang's case was submitted to the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights in January 1999. Its lack of response is in spite of Mrs Mary Robinson"s recent assurances to three Tibetan hunger strikers on April 30, 1999 that Tibetan human rights issue would be addressed at every possible opportunity.

[ top ]

Religious crackdown in Kirti Monastery

Lobsang Sherab, who arrived in India in April 1999, reported a number of arrests that took place in Kirti Monastery in Ngapa County following incidences of independence activity.

Photo of Kirti Monastery

Kirti Monastery is the largest Gelukpa Monastery in Ngapa County, Ngapa Prefecture. The first reported incident was in October 1997, when Gurtson Sherab was arrested and sentenced to seven years" imprisonment. Sherab was arrested for pasting independence posters around the Kirti Monastery and he is currently detained in Mong County Prison.

A second arrested monk's name is not known, although he is known to be the son of Jo Chay, a tailor. The monk is from Amdo Jo-lab and was also arrested in 1997. He was arrested on the charge of pasting independence posters in the Kirti Monastery. He is currently detained in Mong County Prison. Jigme Gotra, a third monk from Kirti Monastery, was arrested in 1996 on the charge of pasting independence posters and was later released. Following his release, he was expelled from his monastery.

Chinese "work team" members arrived in Kirti Monastery in April 1998. Senior Trulku"s, Lama's and teachers of the Kirti Monastery were called to accept the principles of "patriotic re-education". When they refused, they were kept under house arrest for some weeks. Pictures of His Holiness, the Dalai Lama were banned in the monastery and throughout Ngaba County. The "work team" members announced severe penalties for any offenders. In March 1999, an official ceiling was placed on the number of monks allowed to stay in Kirti Monastery. The Chinese "work teams" ordered all monks below the age of 18 years and above the age of 50, to leave the monastery. They emphasised that sooner or later they would be expelled. The monks above the age of 50, were reported to be extremely worried as they have nowhere else to go if they are forced to leave. When the announcement was made, many monks protested to the Chinese authorities. The authorities called on the People's Armed Police (PAP) forces who surrounded the monastery to counteract any reprisals. Since the beginning of 1999, the ìwork teamî members have had to call the PAP forces on three separate ocassions to control the monks. There are currently around 2,300 monks in Kirti Monastery. If the forced depopulation materialises, it is estimated that only about 600 monks will remain.

Control of Kirti School

In 1994, a man named Soypa Naker of Amdo Ngaba County, built a private school in Kirti County which he donated to the Kirti Monastery. Most of the students who attended the school were younger novice monks from Kirti Monastery who could attend without having to pay any fees. The local Chinese authorities persisted many times to force Soypa Naker to handover the administration of his school to the local authorities. They threatened to impose restrictions on the attendance of monks from Kirti Monastery. Eventually, Soypa Naker had no choice but to handover the administration of his school to the authorities in January 1999. Thereafter, the Chinese authorities took total control of the school and gradually instructed monk students to wear laymen's clothes in classes. The students were notified that if they refused to obey the Chinese rules, they would not be allowed into their classrooms. All 40 of the monk students from Kirti Monastery who attend the school now wear laymen's clothes. Moreover, Chinese authorities have now appointed new Chinese teachers to the school. The subjects of Chinese politics and socialist ideology were introduced, and made a compulsory part of the monks" school curriculum. Lobsang Sherab, also known as Pong-go, is an 18 year-old monk from Tharpa town in Ngaba County which is in Ngaba Tibetan Autonomous Prefecture. He arrived in Kathmandu, Nepal on April 19, 1999.

Kirti in Dharamsala

Kirti Institute for Higher Tibetan Studies has been established in exile in Dharamsala, for the purpose of offering young monks from Tibet the opportunity to study Tibetan culture and religion in a conducive environment. The Institute hopes that its students will ultimately return to their monasteries in Tibet.

If any readers wish to obtain more information about Kirti Institute, or offer financial support, please contact direct:

[ top ]

Profile: 15 years for Gaden monk

Bhagdro is a 30-year-old former Gaden monk. He is from Lhasa City, Meldro Gongkar County. He comes from a farming family and is one of three sons. When Bhagdro was young, he studied in the Mangtsuk (Public) School for three years.

Following his schooling, he stayed at home to help his parents on their farm. In 1986, Bhagdro joined Gaden Monastery. Initially he worked as a labourer at the monastery, helping with renovations. Later on he started learning scriptures.

On May 6, 1996, a Chinese "work team" at the Gaden Monastery imposed a total ban on pictures of His Holiness the Dalai Lama. The ban was announced during the "re-education" session conducted by the "work team". Subsequently, a large number of monks disrupted the session. The monks, who numbered about 200, caused an enormous commotion, which left the 18 members of the ìwork teamî with no choice but to abandon the session. Soon after, the large group, led by Bhagdro, approached the "work team" members in their rooms and appealed to them not to carry out the ban as announced. They reasserted that the monks would sacrifice their lives but would not give up pictures of His Holiness, the Dalai Lama. The "work team" members appeared to be threatened by such a big group and immediately left the monastery. That same night the "work team" members returned with reinforcements from the town. About ten trucks full of People's Armed Police (PAP) forces and Public Security Bureau (PSB) officers arrived. The officers surrounded the monastery. When the officers tried to enter the monastery, the monks started throwing stones at them. The PAP started shooting. Two monks were injured in the exchange and eventually the officers overpowered the monks.

The next day the "work team" members and the Democratic Management Committee of the monastery called a meeting with the senior monks. They were ordered to bring their younger students. At the same time, all the pictures that were displayed on the shrines were taken down. The officers recognised Bhagdro from the protest the day before. He was arrested and immediately taken to Gutsa Detention Centre, along with another monk identified as Jampa Lodroe (Poloe). Bhagdro was reportedly
severely beaten, while being transported to Gutsa.

More monks were arrested over time. Some fled from the monastery to other places to escape arrest and punishment. For two months the monastery remained closed. By the end of August 1998, a total of 62 monks and one layman had been arrested. Those who were released after only a few months of detention faced expulsion from the monastery.

In August 1996, Bhagdro was sentenced by the Lhasa Intermediate People's Court. He and Lodroe were both sentenced to 15 years" imprisonment and transferred to Drapchi Prison. The remaining arrested monks were sentenced to two to 15 years imprisonment. Some of the monks were detained in Trisam "re-education through labour" unit. Bhagdro is currently held in Drapchi serving a 15 year sentence.

[
top ]

Expulsion of monks in Drayab Monastery

Ngawang Jampa is an 18-year-old monk from Drayab Monastery. He fled Tibet reaching Nepal on March 3, 1999, following a religious crackdown in his monastery. Jampa joined Drayab Monastery when he was 13 years old.

Four "work team" members came to his monastery in August/September 1997. They were later joined by an additional four members. While it was at the monastery, the eight member ìwork teamîbanned the display of pictures of His Holiness the Dalai Lama and ordered the expulsion of all monks below the age of 25 years.

Prior to the "work team's" arrival in April/May 1998, some monks had pasted independence posters on the walls of the monastery. The posters were hand-written and carried the slogans, "Free Tibet", "No religious freedom" and "Stop banning HHDL pictures". The day after the slogans were pasted, Drayab County officials came to the monastery and interrogated the monks individually. The officials ordered all monks to provide hand-writing samples. They arrested a total of four monks. Jampa later learned that the four monks were each sentenced to eight years" imprisonment and are detained in Chamdo Prison. Only one has been identified and his name is Ngawang (not Ngawang Jampa).

[ top ]

Crackdown at Drupde Monastery

Lhapsum Gyaltsen is a 34 year old former monk from Drupdre Monastery. He became a monk at the age of 23, in 1988. By 1998, there were 71 monks in Drupdre Monastery. In August/September 1998, a six member "work team" came to the monastery from Diru County. For an entire month the "work team" stayed at the monastery conducting "patriotic re-education" sessions. 16 monks who refused to comply were expelled and "stay passes" were issued to 38 more monks. The 17 remaining monks were neither expelled nor issued "stay passes".

Lhapsum, although one of the 38 monks issued with a ìstay passî, preferred not to remain at the monastery. He fled Tibet at the end of 1998 and reached Nepal on January 28, 1999.

Lhapsum comes from a nomadic family in Diru County, Nagchu Prefecture. His family"s livelihood was gravely affected during the snow storm disaster that took place end of 1997 and beginning of 1998. In his county, about 20 families suffered heavy losses. No sufficient relief aid was provided by Chinese authorities, who received bulk international relief funds for the same disaster. Many members of the families affected by the storm have resorted to begging to survive.