Tibetan Centre for Human Rights and Democracy

Human Rights Update and Archives

30 April 1999

The 55TH UN Human Rights Commission and Tibet  [ read ]
Ngawang Woeser adopted as PEN honorary member  [ read ]
15-year-old boy detained two months on suspicion  [ read ]
An appeal letter from Tibet  [ read ]
Patriotic re-education campaign continues  [ read ]
Profile: Distribution of long life prayer leads to monk's arrest  [ read ]
STOP PRESS! President Nelson Mandela to visit China  [ read ]

The 55TH UN Human Rights Commission and Tibet

The United Nations Human Rights Commission did not consider a draft resolution proposed by the United States, (co-sponsored by Poland), on human rights in China, following a no-action motion tabled by the People's Republic of China (PRC). The vote on the no-action motion was 22 votes in favour to 17 against and 14 abstentions. A no-action motion is a procedural manoeuvre, which enables the PRC to block the resolution at the initial stage so that no further discussion is forthcoming. The United States proposed the resolution because of its concern over the deteriorating human rights situation in the PRC since 1998, and in particular the situation in Tibet. It specifically raised the issues of the 11th Panchen Lama and the PRC's refusal to hold dialogue with His Holiness the Dalai Lama.

Had the resolution been accepted, the Commission would have expressed concern at the continuing reports of human rights violations, severe restrictions on the rights of citizens to freedom of non-violent assembly, association, expression and religion as well as the absence of due legal process and the right to a fair trial in China.

The Commission would have expressed concern at increased restrictions on the exercise of cultural, religious and other freedoms of Tibetans. It would have called on the government of the PRC to release all political prisoners, and preserve and protect the distinct cultural, ethnic, linguistic and religious identity of Tibetans and other ethnic groups. Also, it would have called on the PRC to strengthen its bilateral dialogues and its co-operation with the Human Rights Commission and to co-operate fully with all thematic Special Rapporteurs and working groups of the Commission.

The Tibetan Centre for Human Rights and Democracy would like to express its deep regret, disappointment and frustration that the PRC has again been able to avoid being made to account for its continuing disregard for human rights. Unless there is a way to offset the no-action motion, the PRC will continue to circumvent formal scrutiny over its deteriorating human rights situation. This will have grave repercussions for the Tibetan people. The UN Human Rights Commission must address this issue in the interest of upholding the doctrine of universal human rights. On a positive note, the PRC failed to secure seven votes from African countries. The African members of the UN body have traditionally voted in favour of the PRC.

The Tibetan Centre for Human Rights and Democracy applauds the stance taken by the African nations, who either voted against the motion or abstained. The Centre hopes that their support will continue. From April 5, 1999 three Tibetans commenced a hunger strike in front of the UN building in Geneva to draw attention to Tibet's current human rights situation. Their health has reportedly deteriorated drastically, as they approach their 30th day.

The issue of violation of human rights by the PRC was last tabled in 1997 sponsored by the Danish government. The draft resolution failed to obtain the simple majority within the Commission, and was not passed.

[ top ]

Ngawang Woeser adopted as PEN honorary member

Ngawang Woeser The Tibetan Centre for Human Rights and Democracy is pleased to announce the adoption of Ngawang Woeser as an Honorary Member of the Scottish Centre of International PEN. A worldwide association of writers, PEN is an independent, non-government organisation, free from political affiliations. Its membership is drawn worldwide and it is non-western dominated. PEN's mandate is to promote literature throughout the world and to champion the freedom of the written word.

Ngawang Woeser was profiled in our October 31, 1997 Human Rights Update (Volume II Number 20). He was one of the 21 Drepung monks who initiated the famous Lhasa demonstration on September 27, 1987. He was also a founder of the Drepung printing group, which published a number of important documents including a Tibetan translation of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. Originally from the Lhoka Region, Ngawang joined Drepung Monastery when he was 23 years old. Ngawang was first arrested on September 27, 1987 but was released less than six months later. His early release from prison on January 21, 1988, was the result of repeated appeals by the 10th Panchen Lama to the Chinese government. He was later re-arrested when the continuing activities of the "Organisation of Ten" were discovered. Ngawang is currently incarcerated in Drapchi Prison where he is serving a term 17 years imprisonment. At the end of his prison term he will be deprived of his political rights for a further five years. Ngawang was imprisoned for his involvement in various Tibetan freedom activities. These included the formation of a secret organisation, called the "Organisation of Ten", distribution of speeches given by the Dalai Lama, and the translation of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and a document produced by the Tibetan Government-in-Exile, "Future Democratic Constitution of Tibet".

Ngawang will complete his sentence in the year 2006, if it is not increased while he is in detention. PEN would like Ngawang's family to know that he is in its members" thoughts and that they are working hard for his release.

[ top ]

15-year-old boy detained two months on suspicion

15-year-old Yeshi Yarphel was detained in late February 1999, accused of being a spy for the Tibetan Government-in-Exile. In 1991,Yeshi's parents sent him to Dharamsala to receive a proper Tibetan education in India. After studying in India for eight years, Yeshi left school in late February 1999 because of family problems.

Yeshi's father is a former political prisoner who served 18 years imprisonment in a Chinese prison. While in prison, Yeshi's father suffered severe torture. As Yeshi is the only son, when his father turned 60 years old there was no one to look after his aged parents. Consequently, Yeshi was called back from school in India.

Yeshi was arrested by the People's Armed Police in late February 1999 who suspecting him of being spy. He was taken to Nyari detention centre in Shigatse. PRC officials later alleged that Yeshi was carrying out espionage activities for the Tibetan Government in-Exile. He was released in late April 1999 after being detained for a total of two months in Nyari Detention Centre, merely on the basis of suspicion. During his detention, Yeshi's parents were not allowed to visit him. Despite his youth, the authorities treated him in the same manner in which they treated adult prisoners.

[ top ]

An appeal letter from Tibet

The following letter was handed to an Australian traveller in Tibet on the eve of the 50th Anniversary of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR), December 9, 1998. It is written by the "Cholsum Tibetan's Youth Organisation" in Tibet:

Honourable Excellency UN Secretary General, High Commissioner United Nations, High Commissioner for Refugees, Heads of the States of all the countries, President of Amnesty International, government and non governmental organisations, learned dissidents and leaders of the Chinese democratic movement.

We the Tibetan people, would like to strongly appeal to you all, from the core of our hearts, that from September 27, 1987 to December 1, 1998 monks, nuns and common Tibetan people initiated non-violent processions and demonstrations based on reason and truth on numerous occasions to free Tibet from Chinese occupation.

Imprisoned political prisoners under Chinese rule are severely tortured and their blood is extracted. Some are secretly killed and forced to perform continuous hard work with chained feet. Sick prisoners are left to die as they are provided with either no medical treatment or treatment that is too late. Even those prisoners who are released, after serving their sentences face immense hardship. Monks and nuns are expelled from their monasteries and nunneries and those from offices and co-operatives are dismissed as their names are struck off the work register. Chinese officials closely watch those who are independent technicians and businessmen, making their lives miserable and impossible. It is sheer shamelessness on the part of Chinese government, and still it continues. Above all, Tibet's 11th Panchen Lama, ten year-old Gedhun Choekyi Nyima, is being detained and the whereabouts of this child and his health condition are still not known. Since 1993, under the instruction of the Chinese government, notices were served to discontinue all teaching of Tibetan culture and to halt teaching in the Tibetan language in Tibet University. Elementary Tibetan lessons in primary school are taught by Chinese methods. According to the notice, classes conducted using Tibetan Buddhist methods could expose teachers as counter-revolutionaries. In November 1998, at the Lhasa Elementary School one question for the "No. 1 Examination", Lhasa Educational Board exam was, "Who is the head of the splittist movement?" When the students avoided answering the question, the helpless teacher told them that there is no alternative but to answer that the "head of the splittists" is the Dalai Lama.

The Chinese population is increasing each passing day and, at the same time, Tibetan women are restricted to having only one or two children. After the birth of their first child, women must wait for another three years before they may have a second. If a child is born before the expiry of three-year gap period, a penalty of 500 yuan is levied on the child. We hereby appeal to everyone concerned to deal with the deteriorating situation of Tibetans, free Tibet from Chinese occupation and support the just struggle. International bodies need to intensify their existing support and to tranform actions into tangible result for the Tibetan people. They need to emphasise the need to exert more pressure on the Chinese regime through the United Nations Human Rights Commission, exposing China's shameless and ruthless behaviour in Tibet.

From the World Peace loving, Cholsum Tibetans and Tibetan Youth Organisation involved in the Independence movement in occupied Tibet, on December 7, 1998.

[ top ]

Patriotic re-education campaign continues

The patriotic re-education campaign is still in force in monasteries in Tibet. On December 3, 1998 a Chinese work- team issued an order to the monasteries in Ngaba County to gather at the township the following day, according to local monk who wishes to remain anonymous. Prior to the announcement, the authorities distributed re-education booklets in the monasteries, including the local Drongu Monastery.

On the evening of the order, the informant monk worked from 8 pm, until 12 midnight to sketch the Tibetan national flag and write out 30 pages of political slogans. The slogans included pleas such as "Long Live H.H the Dalai Lama", "Tibet is independent" and "Denounce the Panchen Lama selected by Chinese authorities". The monk hoisted the national flag and pasted the slogans as wall posters, in the town. The following day, seven County work-team officials arrived at the town at 9 am. They were enraged to see the flag and posters. They immediately ordered the monks to pull down the Tibetan flag and remove all of the posters. The officials later threatened the monks for almost three hours, explaining the serious consequences that the culprit or culprits would face if caught.

The following day, on December 4, 1998, at 12 noon the work-team commenced the patriotic re-education campaign at Drongu Monastery. Every monk between the ages of 18 and 50 years was required to obtain an identity card. All others monks were to be expelled from the monastery.

Implementation of the orders would mean that only 30 of 170 monks would be entitled to remain in the monastery. Many senior monks are concerned about the effect of the order on religious education. Seven members of the work-team returned to Dongru Monastery on the evening of December 16, 1998. They pretended to know who had carried the protest activities and interrogated several monks for the following three days. The work-team members were unable to uncover any information. The patriotic re-education campaign is clearly continuing in Dongru and all other monasteries in Ngaba County. Due to the religious repression in his monastery, the informant monk left Tibet on March 17, 1999 and arrived in Dharamsala on April 25, 1999. He was imprisoned by the Chinese border police in Nyelam and Dram for a total of eight days before he was able to make it to India.

[ top ]

Profile: Distribution of long life prayer leads to monk's arrest

Kalsang, also known as Jamyang Gyatso, is a 29 year-old monk from Gyalste Palchoe Monastery in the Tibet Autonomous Region (TAR). In November 1996, Kalsang visited Drepung Monastery in Lhasa to seek blessings from the revered Lamring Rinpoche. While he was in Lhasa, Kalsang obtained a copy of the long-life prayer composed by His Holiness the Dalai Lama for the reincarnate Panchen Rinpoche, Gedhun Choekyi Nyima. He took the prayer back to his monastery where he distributed it to his fellow monks and other people in his locality. At the same time, he informed local people about the plight of the 11th Panchen Lama. The 11th Panchen Lama is revered as the second highest religious leader of Tibet, and has been missing since 1995. His Holiness the Dalai Lama recognised the reincarnate 11th Panchen Lama in May 1995, when the boy was six years old. To date the Chinese authorities have not permitted any independent human rights monitor or UN official to visit the child or his parents, despite repeated requests. The Chinese justify holding the child in custody on the basis that his parents allegedly sought "security for the child from external danger".

In the meantime, the PRC has appointed its own Panchen Lama and pressures Tibetans in Tibet to recognise him as the true reincarnation. Many Tibetans have been arrested for acts as simple as printing and distributing the long-life prayer, composed by His Holiness the Dalai Lama for the true reincarnate lama. Pictures of the Chinese appointed Panchen Lama are installed in monasteries and nunneries all over Tibet, including the Potala Palace.

The Gyaltse Public Security Bureau (PSB) became aware of Kalsang's activities and, on November 20, 1996, he was arrested. He was immediately taken to Gyaltse Detention Centre where he was interrogated. He faced brutal beatings during the interrogation and was detained for a period of one month. After one month, he was transferred to Nyari Detention Centre in Shigatse.

In Nyari, he continued to suffer severe beatings at the hands of the prison authorities. In March 1997, he was tried on a charge of distributing "counter-revolutionary propaganda". He was sentenced to four years and six months in prison. He was also deprived of all political rights for a further year.

After four months of incarceration in Nyari Detention Centre, Kalsang was transferred to Drapchi Prison, the TAR ìNo. 1î prison, where he continues to serve his prison term.

Kalsang is the youngest of four children. He comes from a reasonably well-to-do family. Prior to his retirement, his father was the mayor of his town and one of his brothers trained to be a doctor. Kalsang attended school for seven years and completed his primary school in Zhuntsug schools, which were established by the PRC government. He joined Gyaltse Palchoe Monastery when he was 16 years old as a novice monk and was ordained in 1987.

[ top ]

STOP PRESS!
President Nelson Mandela to visit China

On May 5-7, 1999 President Nelson Mandela will visit the PRC. The visit will be one of his last official foreign visits as the President of South Africa. As an international advocate for peace and an active supporter of the Tibetan community, TCHRD is hopeful that President Mandela will voice his concern for the PRC's human rights abuses in China and Tibet.