Tibetan Centre for Human Rights and Democracy

Human Rights Update and Archives

31 August 1998

11-year-old arrested, beaten and imprisoned  [ read ]
Imprisoned for poster  [ read ]
Expulsion of all the nuns at Toerong Nunnery  [ read ]
New restrictions imposed in Toeshung Choephel Monastery  [ read ]
"Strike Hard" and expulsions continue  [ read ]
Profile: Young monk beaten to death  [ read ]
Monks expelled from Pashoe Monastery  [ read ]
Our sponsor for this issue  [ read ]

11-year-old arrested, beaten and imprisoned

Sixteen-year-old Tenzin Tsedup of Taktse County in Thangkar township recounts his life's bitter experience at the hands of Chinese Police. A former monk of Taktse Phagmo monastery, he joined the monastery when he was only seven years old. He was at the monastery for only four years when he was arrested for involvement in political activities followed by his arrest and detention.

On August 17, 1993, Tenzin and his friends Tsetan Ngodup (19) and Pasang (23), left for Lhasa from their monastery to demonstrate at the Drepung Shoton (yogurt) festival held on August 18, 1993 in Norbulinka, Lhasa. At about 11 pm in the night by bicycle they carried the national flag and several independence leaflets and headed for Lhasa. On their way, they hoisted the flag and pasted wall posters on the gate of Thangkar township People's Government Office and then proceeded for Lhasa.

At the festival there were many people gathere.Taking advantage of the situation, the three of them went up on the stage, and started shouting slogans such as ěTibet is independentî, ěLong live His Holiness the Dalai Lamaî and ěChinese quit Tibet". They were immediately arrested by the officials of the Public Security Bureau (PSB) and taken to Gutsa Detention Centre. At the time of their arrest, they were brutally beaten.

Upon reaching Gutsa, a Chinese police kicked Tenzin on his chest and he fell unconscious. When he regained his consciousness, he was provided with a little water and moments later, they started to interrogate him.

On September 13, 1993 when the monks were in Gutsa, three PSB officials from Thangkar county came to them. The officials found out about the trio"s involvement in the earlier flag and the poster incident again beat them severely. They splashed hot boiling water on Pasang's right arm and threw a chair after that on the same arm. Today, he still has a prominent scar on his arm and he is not able to lift anything heavy.

On September 14, 1993 the monks were formally arrested and their sentences were passed. Pasang was sentenced to six years, Tseten Ngodup to four and Tenzin to one year. Tseten and Pasang were transferred to Drapchi whereas Tenzin continued to serve his term in Gutsa, working in a vegetable garden.

On August 18, 1994 Tenzin was released. He was not allowed to rejoin any other monastery. So, he had to stay at home.

In early 1998, he tried to escape to India along with 23 people, but was arrested at the Tibet-Nepal border near Shar Kumbu by Chinese patrolling police. He was detained in Shigatse Detention Centre for about a month then returned to his home town. He made his second escape attempt in April 1998 and was successful. He finally reached India in August 1998.

[ top ]

Imprisoned for poster

Migmar Tsering was only 19 when he and his other young friends were involved in political activities for which they served time in prison.

Having completed his term Migmar is today in exile. "My name is Migmar Tsering, aged 25, from Lhoka Gongkar Chideshol, Toephues Choekhor Monastery. I joined the monastery when I was 13 years old in 1986.

"On 31 July 1992, along with two other monks from the same monastery, Tsering (18) and Lhakpa Tsering (17), we made independence posters and a Tibetan flag and pasted them in Chideshol township to correspond with the next day celebration of the founding anniversary of the People's Liberation Army. or almost a month our involvement was undiscovered. However, on August 28, 1992, we were arrested by PSB officials of Lhoka region. We were taken to Lhoka Tsethang Detention Centre where we were kicked, boxed and beaten while being interrogated.

"On November 9, 1992 our sentences were passed by the Lhoka People's Intermediate Court charged with ěcounterrevolutionaryî propaganda. I was sentenced to four years and six months and Tsering to four years. We were both sentenced to two years deprivation of political rights whereas Lhakpa Tsering was sentenced to two years and one year deprivation of political rights. After our sentencing, we were transferred to Drapchi prison fifth unit.

"In Drapchi, we did prison labour which involved working in the vegetable garden. Regulations are very strictly controlled. Prisoners who fail to meet with the expectations of the authorities receive severe repercussions. I remember one time when I was beaten for getting delayed for the garden work. After the completion of my prison term on February 7, 1997, I was released.

"However, I was debarred from rejoining any other monastery. Life outside prison was extremely difficult for me and I was subjected to strict vigilance and restrictions were imposed on my every movement. Not being able to bear all this, I was compelled to leave Tibet and come to India."

[ top ]

Expulsion of all the nuns at Toerong Nunnery

Toerong Nunnery in Sho Re township in Lhoka Region faced similar fate at the hands of the "work-team". All the nuns at the nunnery were expelled and their rooms were demolished with help from the local villagers to ensure that the nuns would not return after their expulsion.

Tashi Paldon, 25 years old, is from Danak County in Lhoka Region. She was a nun at the Toerong Nunnery in Danak County in Lhoka region. This nunnery was constructed by Pawoe Rinpoche of Nyingma (a sect in Tibetan Buddhism) Lama.

This nunnery had been completely destroyed by the Chinese during the Cultural Revolution. However, it was rebuilt in 1996 by 20 nuns. Tashi was among the nuns who had rebuilt the nunnery.

In July-August, 1997, a four member "work-team" came to the nunnery to conduct a "patriotic re-education" campaign. The nuns were told to oppose the Dalai Lama and his "splittist" activities.

Not one of the nuns accepted the principles posed by the work-team. As a result, the infuriated the members expelled all 23 nuns and told them to return to their places of origin. The "work-team" also ordered the demolishment of the rooms of the nuns by the local people living near the nunnery. The nuns were left with no place to stay therefore, they were compelled to leave for their respective homes.

Tashi Paldon, along with Lhakyi and Norzom went to Samye Chee Gur Waen Tsa Monastery"s Retreat Centre, where they planned to build a small house for their meditation.

However, in February 1998, their plans were crushed when "work-team" members came to the monastery to conduct a 're-education campaign'. The "work-team" members recognised Tashi and her friends and told them leave that place immediately and return to their respective houses.

They were also threatened that if they were found at some other place, then they will have them arrested and put behind bars.

[ top ]

New restrictions imposed in Toeshung Choephel Monastery

New restrictions were introduced with regard to the "patriotic re-education" campaign in Toeshung Choephel Monastery in Chael Dae township in Lhoka region. Migmar Gyaltsen (27), a former monk from the same monastery faced expulsion for refusing to follow the instructions of the "work-team".

New regulations were imposed upon the monks of Toeshung Choephel monastery. The monks are not allowed to wear their monastic robes or conduct any religious ceremonies.

On March 20, 1996, a Chinese "work team" entered the monastery to conduct a "patriotic re-education" campaign. They stayed at the monastery for nine months and attempted to force the monks to oppose the Dalai Lama and denounce the Panchen Lama recognised by the Dalai Lama.

Migmar Gyaltsen could not follow these principles and refused to comply. This resulted in his arrest followed by detention for a month after which time, he was expelled from the monastery.

[ top ]

"Strike Hard" and expulsions continue

Chungwang is a 21-year-old nun from Gongkar County in Lhoka region. She was a nun at Lhoka Samye Chee Gu Lhakhang Ser Po Nunnery. Chungwang relates the expulsion of thirteen nuns from her nunnery.

A six membered "work-team" came to their nunnery to conduct a "re-education" campaign. All six men were Tibetans.

Prior to the arrival of the "work-team", there were about 51 nuns in the nunnery. The "work-team" ordered the nuns to oppose the Dalai Lama and all the pictures of His Holiness to be brought down from the altar. The nuns were told that his pictures were totally banned.

The "work-team" members held "re-education" sessions. During one of these sessions, some of the nuns expressed dissatisfaction about the presence of the "work-team" and their instructions in the nunnery.

This resulted in the expulsion of 13 nuns. Some of them were: Chungwang, Tsering Wangmo (22), Tashi Paldon (25), Dechen Dolma (26), Pasang (20), Kalsang (19), Pasang (20), Dawa and Wangmo (22). All these nuns were told to return to their respective homes. Some of them even fled to India.

[ top ]

Profile: Young monk beaten to death

Sangye Tenphel's story exemplifies a case of a horrific death in custody ignored by prison officials. His intrepid behaviour of expressing his views cost him his life. Sangye Tenphel whose layname is Gonpo Dorjee was from Khangmar Monastery in Damshung County, in Lhasa City. Arrested for his involvement in political activities, Sangye died within the first year of his prison term. He was 19 years old.

On April 10, 1995, Sangye Tenphel, along with four other monks from Khangmar Monastery, held a pro-independence demonstration in Lhasa. All the monks were immediately arrested and detained in the Gutsa Detention Centre.

Sangye and his companions were subjected to severe interrogation sessions where they were badly beaten. Their sentences were later passed by the Lhasa People's Intermediate Court. Lobsang Gelek and Tenzin Choedak were sentenced to five years; Lobsang Choephel to four years; Tenzin Choephel and Sangye Tenphel to three years respectively.

In October 1995, the five monks from Khangmar Monastery were transferred to Drapchi Prison. Upon their arrival in Drapchi, they were reported to have been subjected to torture and beatings. One day in November 1995, all the prisoners in the fifth unit were called for a random inspection. At that time one of the prisoner was found missing out of the 64 inmates. Paljor, the prison authority of the fifth unit enquired about the missing person and the head of the prisoners, Ngawang Tensang, affirmed there were no absenties. Ngawang was reprimanded by Paljor for negligence and kept in solitary confinement.

After the incident when the prisoners were later sent back to their cells, the prisoners refused to leave. They requested for the release of Ngawang Tensang. This was seen as an act of misconduct by prison officials who made them stand up with their faces against the wall while the prison warden scolded them. After some time, Phuntsok, the chief warden of Drapchi prison came and dispersed them.

Sangye was persistent and raised concern over Ngawang Tensang's confinement and asked why he was singled out for punishment. His comments were held in contempt and he was later called for interrogations by the prison official where he was beaten all over his body. From then on Sangye was singled out under strict scrutiny.

On January 30, 1996 the annual meeting of the Drapchi prison was held. The prisoners were all issued with a form to fill in. The prisoners were evaluated in accordance to the answers that appeared on their forms. Three monks wrote negative answers and were put in solitary confinement. They were Bhuchung (21) from Gaden Choekor Monastery; Thinley Ngawang from Tashi Gang Monastery in Phenpo, and Drubthog (21) from Chongyal County in Lhoka Region.

The prisoners of the fifth unit demanded that the three prisoners be taken out of isolation or else they would convene a hunger strike. All the prisoners stood in the courtyard of their prison unit. The prisoners were immediately surrounded by police and People's Armed Police (PAP) officials. An order came from the chief prison official that the prisoners would be given five minutes to vacate the area. If they refused, the PAP men would take immediate action against them. The prisoners had no choice but to comply. At the time when the prisoners dispersed, Sangye was overheard by one of the prison guards saying, "today we could not do anything".

He was immediately summoned to the prison office and subjected to interrogations. He faced harsh beatings and torture over his entire body. He was held from both his arms by two men, one on each side when another two struck on his head several times with a stick.

Inmates from Drapchi later saw him staggering towards his cell. Not long after the beatings Sangye started to have health complications. When he was taken to the doctor at the prison hospital, he was told he had no health problems and given no medication. However, his health worsened to such an extent that for almost a week he lay insensate on his bed.

Finally, he was allowed to visit the PSB hospital on May 5, 1996. He was assisted by a few prison hospital officials.

He died the next day on May 6, 1996. His dead body was not handed over to his relatives but was taken to Sera Cremation ground with the help of a prisoner.

On May 9, 1996, Phuntsok, the chief warden of Drapchi prison called on the prisoners of the fifth unit, and held a meeting. He announced in the meeting that Sangye Tenphel died as result of brain hemorrhage.

The prisoners in Drapchi appealed to the chief prison guard to take all the necessary actions against the people who had beaten Sangye. However, so far no action has been taken.

[ top ]

Monks expelled from Pashoe Monastery

40 monks whose parents are government officials face expulsion. A "work-team" in Pashoe Monastery has introduced a new policy where monks whose parents work for the government are subjected to expulsions. About 20 monks and another 20 novice monks have so far been expelled.

Jampa Choeden, 24 years old, is from Kochen village in Pashoe County, Chamdo Region. He was a monk of Pashoe Monastery where 370 monks lived in 1996.

On August 1, 1996, a ten membered "work-team" from the county came to the monastery to conduct "patriotic re-education" campaign from the county. Two of the members were Chinese and the rest were all Tibetans. The "work-team" members stayed at the monastery for a month.

During this time, the monks were not allowed to perform any religious rituals in the monastery. 70 monks from the monastery were also expelled because they were not present when the "work-team" had arrived at the monastery. They had gone for pilgrimage or to their villages to meet their relatives. No reasons were provided for their expulsion.

Jampa Choeden was among those expelled. He stayed with his family until the "work-team" members left the monastery. When he rejoined the monastery, he was not allowed to attend any of the meetings of the monastery.

On February 15, 1998, the "work-team" revisited the monastery for the second time with 13 members including Chinese.

Upon their arrival, the "work-team" conducted a a roll call of the monks. All the 54 novice monks below the age of 18 were expelled from the monastery.

The children of all government officials were also expelled including 20 monks and 20. The "work-team" stayed in the monastery for two months. All the expenses incurred by the "work-team" members had to be borne by the monastery. There are at present only 180 monks in the monastery.

[ top ]

Our sponsor for this issue

The Tibetan Centre for Human Rights and Democracy would like to thank Rev. Timothy J. Connor and his church in Oslo, Norway, for their contribution towards sponsoring this edition of the Human Rights Update.

We thank you sincerely for keeping us in your thoughts and including us in your prayers.