Tibetan Centre for Human Rights and Democracy

Human Rights Update and Archives

15 December 1997

Freedom of expression void  [ read ]
Birth control policy in Amdo  [ read ]
85 Tibetan women sterilised  [ read ]
Re-education  [ read ]
New temple and monastic rules  [ read ]
More monasteries targeted  [ read ]
Airport expansion in Lhoka  [ read ]
Two nuns expelled  [ read ]

Freedom of expression void

Chinese President Jiang Zemin claimed, "China's citizens enjoy the freedom of assembly, speech and demonstration and protests", during his visit to Canada on November 29, 1997. In contrast with this, hundreds of Tibetans have been arrested by Chinese authorities solely for voicing their opinions or gathering to peacefully call for human rights respect in Tibet. Four new cases of Tibetans arrested for expressing their religious and political views have been received.

Photo of Menpa Dorjee Menpa Dorjee, a 55-year-old from Rebkong County in Tsongon (Ch: Qinghai) County, was arrested in March 1997 for hanging the Tibetan national flag in the middle of the street of Rebkong City during Monlam (prayer) festival. Public Security Bureau (PSB) officials subsequently raided his room and confiscated documents and books on Tibet. He was sentenced to one year and six months imprisoment in early November this year.

Menpa Dorjee was a physician in allopathic medicine, which he learned from a famous allopathic doctor called "Barefoot Doctors" during the Cultural Revolution. In the early eighties, he worked in different religious activities and later in 1986 he bought a zerox machine and used it to make copies of documents and books on Tibetan independence.

Menpa Dorjee has extensive knowledge of traditional Tibetan language, medicine, history, art and calligraphy. He used to write rare Buddhist texts for the monastery, draw portraits, and made a computer script for Tibetan language.

Ngawang Tendar is a 29-year-old monk from Jampa Ling Monastery in Tsawa Pomda Village in Chamdo Region under "Tibet Autonomous Region". He joined the monastery in 1990.

On 1 August 1995, Ngawang with three other friends went to the annual summer picnic festival. When they felt that the crowd had grown big enough they started shouting pro-independence slogans such as "Free Tibet" and "Long Live His Holiness the Dalai Lama".

They were subsequently arrested by the Tsawa Pashoe County PS B and were then handed over to the Chamdo PSB. The other three monks were released after three months of imprisonment. However, Ngawang was regarded as having spearheaded the demonstration and continues to be held without charge.

Pentse, a prisoner in Lhasa's Drapchi prison, reportedly shouted "Free Tibet" during a visit by a foreign delegation to the prison. Two other prisoners also supported Pentse's comment. The three prisoners were said to have been put in a dreaded cell and threatened with execution.

Photo of Ngawang Phelgay Ngawang Phelgay is a 26-year-old monk from Drepung Monastery. On 22 October 1997, he reportedly brought down the Chinese National Flag hoisted on the Drepung Monastery and tamped on it. He was subsequently arrested and interrogated for his actions.

During the time of interrogations he is reported to have said, "No one instigated me to do this. I am doing this out of sheer frustration for the presence of work teams in the monasteries who have deprived us of the right to freedom of religion".

Tsultrim Dhargey, a 26-year-old monk, was said to be in a state close to death following more than two years detention, according to a new arrival from Tibet (name withheld) who met with him on 13th October 1997.

Tsultrim is from Ragya Monastery in Machen County, Golok Tibetan Autonomous Prefecture under Tsongon (Ch: Qinghai) Province. He first visited India in 1990 for pilgrimage and studied in Sera Monastery in south India until his return to Tibet in 1993.

While crossing the Himalayan border, Ngawang and two of his friends were arrested by the PSB of Nyalam County and detained for a few days. They were then transferred to Lhasa PSB and later to Qinghai Province PSB. They were released after two months of severe interrogations and torture. In May 1994, Tsultrim was arrested by the Public Security Bureau of Machen County and detained for 6 months.

In July 1995, Tsultrim was again arrested by the Machen County PSB and detained for 20 months. During his detention he was reportedly beaten by PSB officials on many occasions and injected with a toxic fluid which caused him to lose consciousness. When he was released in February 1997, he was beyond recognition even of his family.

[ top ]

Birth control policy in Amdo

The Chinese authorities claim to have achieved good results with regard to the implementation of their birth control policy in Tso Jang (Ch: Haibei) Tibetan Autonomous Prefecture in Qinghai Province.

It was reported in the Qinghai Tibetan Daily Newspaper on 8 August 1997 that, in 1996, the birth control officials succeeded in inserting contraceptive coils in 2958 women in the region. This has reportedly resulted in reducing the birth rate of the region from 86.13% to 85.73%.

The Chinese Communist Party and government officials have implemented the birth control policy in accordance with the following points:

  1. Regulation of birth control policy and economic development; implementation of research in those field; timely deciding of critical issues and problems; administration of birth control offices and policy.
  2. Strictly observing the gap between the children born and to control birth due to illiteracy of the policy.
  3. Strict enforcement and practice of the above regulations.
  4. Provision of support and guidance to poor and destitute families in advance; helping the people of the region and striving for a middle class economy by lowering the birth rate and strengthening the economic status.

[ top ]

85 Tibetan women sterilised

In Chabcha district in Tsolho (Ch: Hainan) Tibetan Autonomous Prefecture under Tsongon, Chinese authorities have launched a strict birth control policy. Since the start of 1997, 85 Tibetan women have been sterilised and 113 were force to go undergo abortions. This appeared in the Official Qinghai Tibetan Daily Newspaper published on 12 June 1997.

This incident took place in 13 villages in Chabcha County under Tsongon (Ch: Qinghai) county. The regional head of Chabcha County passed a resolution to implement the birth control policy and decided to award those in the village who best succeed in implementing the policy. Under this policy, 31 women from Sadrushi village were sterilised, 18 women were inserted with contraceptive devices and 14 Tibetan women from Changshe village of the Chabcha district underwent sterilisation.

[ top ]

Re-education

In Kain Lho In 1997, Chinese authorities launched the "re-education" campaign in all monasteries in the Kan Lho Tibetan Autonomous Prefecture under Gansu Province. Officials from the PSB and the Religious Bureau of Kan Lho were sent to monasteries to teach socialist values and force monks to destroy pictures of the Dalai Lama and the Panchen Lama recognised by Dalai Lama, and to believe in and display pictures of Gyaltsen Norbu - China's choice of "Panchen Lama".

In Machu County, officials forced monks to buy pictures of Gyaltsen Norbu which come in three different sizes. The large one costs 25 yuan, the medium 10 yuan and the small one 2 yuan.

[ top ]

New temple and monastic rules

The following is a translation from Tibetan of "Lhasa Municipality's Monastic (temples and hermitages) Disciplinary Rules for Monks and Nuns":

  1. One must protect law and order, property of the people, unity of the nationalities, unity of the motherland and oppose the splittists.
  2. One must respect the leaders of the party and the government, the socialist system, and the policy and rules laid down by the officials of the region.
  3. No one is allowed to listen to or disseminate reactionary propaganda which threatens or harms the unity and security of the country, possess or distribute reactionary literature, audio and video tapes or participate in any sort of splittist activity.
  4. One must accept the rules laid down by the Democratic Management Committee of the monastery (temples and hermitages), work for the welfare of the society and monastery, actively participate in the production and labour works.
  5. One must listen to the advice given by the teachers and officials of the monasteries and maintain solidarity between old and young.
  6. One must show sincere faith in the Buddha, study all subjects of Buddhism and strive for its flourishing.
  7. Monks and nuns must strictly abide by the monastic vows and religious discipline of the monastery. They must be humble and bear good characters, and should wear monastic robes unless it is an exceptional circumstance.
  8. No one can oppose the government and legal officials in the name of religion or intrude in the re-education.
  9. One must preserve cultural monuments and artefacts, monasteries and public property.
  10. One must take an interest in environment and personal health. The monks and nuns must preserve the image of monastic community and work hard to become good monks and nuns who love religion and nation and abide by the law.
Nationalities and Religious Bureau of Lhasa Municipality. 20.7.1997

[ top ]

More monasteries targeted

Thupten Soepa is from Rame Kyishong town in Lhoka Gongkar county and was a monk at Rame monastery. Thupten reports that on 1 March, 1997, an eight-member work team arrived at the monastery. They started the re-education session and ordered that photographs of the Dalai Lama be taken down.

"Initially, none of the monks were willing to meet their demands and refused to comply with their orders," says Thupten. "Then the members made threats that our parents would also be made to suffer and many of us had no choice. In the space of a month our parents were called twice to ensure that we listened to their instructions.

"There were three of us who refused to obey the work-team and as a result we were expelled from the monastery on 5/4/97. The other two monks were Inchung la, a 48-year-old from Tharpaling in Lhoka, and Tsering, a 38-year-old from Toelung Dechen county. Before we were expelled we had to give an ink handprint on the expulsion record and then we were sent home and ordered not to ever return to the monastery again nor join any other monastery. We were also prohibited from moving about freely within Tibet and if we wished to go to Lhasa we had to seek permission.

"The work-team was at our monastery for six months. They stayed in the private chamber of the Dalai Lama and for their entire stay they lived on the expenses of the monastery. If we were late by one minute we were fined 5 yuan and if we did not turn up at all, we were fined 10 yuan.

They told us, 'Even if you do not obey our instructions here in the monastery, you will not escape the re-education session because you will have no choice when we conduct it in your homes at a later stage. Therefore, it will be much easier for you here in the monastery'."

"While they were at the monastery, they took note of all the Kusung Thugten (religious artifacts) and took photographs of all the sacred things in the monastery. This made it difficult for us to conduct special prayers because we had to seek prior permission to retrieve the statues and idols from the cupboard."

Closure of a monastery:

"Another monastery called Sungrabling in Lhoka had more than 70 monks. In May this year the monastery was finally closed down after repeated expulsions of monks. There were 25 monks when they closed down the monastery and now it is completely empty. The Chinese authorities accused the monastery of having dealings with the Tibetan exile government. The caretaker was also expelled and the head of the monastery was taken to Tsethang for four days of interrogation before being sent home. As he was an old man the authorities did not imprison him. Two policeman came to the monastery and took many of the sacred objects to the county office".

Arrest:

Thupten also reported that a monk named Khedrup, originally from Tharpaling, was detained from Gongkar Choede monastery for refusing to obey the instructions of the work-team members. Khedrup, about 18 years old, was sentenced to six years and is presently in Tsethang prison.

Workteam in Namrab Monastery:

In Namrab monastery, says Thupten, four monks out of 48 were expelled when work-teams came to their monastery.

[ top ]

Airport Expansion in Lhoka

About four years ago, an airport was built in Kyishong sub-district in Lhoka County. Kyishong is one of the best known places in Tibet for excellent harvests and many Tibetans in this area had to give up their land for construction and thereby lost their means of livelihood. In mid-February 1997, just after Tibetan New Year, expansion of this airport began and many more Tibetans had to give up their land.

The people were told that this expansion was necessary for the people who would be returning from Hong Kong. Fifteen trucks arrived, each carrying 70 workers. All of the workers were Chinese brought from China and houses were built alongside the construction as temporary sheltering for them. Those Tibetans to whom the land had belonged were given a certificate granting them permission to work as a road constructor and some were given about 1000 yuan as compensation.

Thupten says, "I have strong feelings that the Chinese will stay back even after the construction is completed. A few years ago more than 300 Chinese came to work on a similar project in Gongkar county. They built a carpentry factory and all of the logs were carried out from Kongpo region (Ch:Nyintri) in Tibet Autonomous Region. After one year the factory was closed down but all of the Chinese are still living in Gongkar and have built homes and own shops. Some of them work in government offices. Now, with the transfer of more than 1000 workers for the construction of the airport in Gongkar, the Tibetans are totally outnumbered by the Chinese."

Military Construction:

Thupten also reported on the construction of a military cantonment currently underway close to his monastery. "At many places in Lhoka, there are military cantonments being built. Within this year alone, about 15 military base camps were built in the fields and more are built close to the Tsangpo.

Birth Control Policy:

In a village in Lhoka called Koja with about 100 families, about 40 women have been sterilised and many more have been given contraceptives. In some cases, these contraceptives have rendered women infertile. Young girls not yet married are also given these contraceptive pills.

[ top ]

Two nuns expelled

Lobsang Dolkar is a 22-year-old nun from Gonpa Phug nunnery in Dongkar Shang, Nyemo county under Lhasa city. Lobsang joined the nunnery in 1990. At that time, there were only nine nuns which later increased to 15. On 5 June 1997, she was expelled from the nunnery along with another nun for not having obeyed the principles of the workteam members.

On 9 March, 1997, a six-member work team had arrived at the nunnery and started the "re-education" sessions. Many rules were made which included restrictions on freedom of monement. The nuns' behaviour was observed and recorded since the date of their arrival in the nunnery. They were given four books to study according and were expected to follow the principles laid down which included opposing the Dalai Lama.

The "re-education sessions" went on for three months during which time the nuns at no point of time obeyed the ideologies. As a result, the work team called the parents and relatives of the nuns to the nunnery and told them to advise the nuns.

Despite these heavy threats, Lobsang Dolkar and one of her friends refused to follow the instructions of the work team members. They were expelled from the nunnery on 5 June 1997. Subsequent to their expulsion, four other nuns were also expelled on similar grounds. Four months after Lobsang and her friend's expulsion, they decided to flee to India.

The work team is reported to have stayed at the nunnery for a total of four months. When they left there were only remaining in the nunnery.

Lobsang further also reports on the plight of four nuns from Rangjung nunnery in Nyemo county under Lhasa city, who had participated in a demonstration in Lhasa in 1994 to show their support for peace marchers from India. These nuns were: Sangye Chodon (27), Tsering Chozom (22), Dekyi Yangzom (21) and Trinlay Dolkar (21). Sangye Chodon was later sentenced to 6 years, while other three were sentenced for 4 years. They were first detained in Gutsa detention Centre, and after being sentenced, they were transferred to Drapchi prison.

Ranjung nunnery also faced expulsion after workteam members arrived. The nunnery previously had 35 nuns, out of which only 24 remain.