Tibetan Centre for Human Rights and Democracy

Publications

Annual Report 2001

Right to Livelihood - Notes

[Back to Chapter 1.1]

1. Article 1(2) ICESCR

2. Article 7 ICESCR

3. Article 9 ICESCR

4. Article 2(2) ICESCR obliges governments to ensure that all rights in the Covenant are exercised without discrimination of any kind as to race, as well as gender, language, religion, politics etc. International Convention on Elimination of Racial Discrimination also obliges governments to take affirmative action to assist people fight against discrimination.

5. Article 2 (2) UNDRD, emphasis added

6. TIN, News Review No 27 – Reports from Tibet, 1998, London UK, pp.59-64

7. Information Office of State Council, New Progress in Human Rights in the Tibet Autonomous Region, Beijing, 1998; all White Papers referred to have been taken from Xinhuanet and do not contain paragraph or page references

8. DIIR, Tibet 2000: Environment and Development Issues, Dharamsala India, 2000, p.42

9. ibid

10. DIIR, Tibet Under Communist China: 50 years, 2001, Dharamsala, India, p.51

11. Chinese Radio International 2/11/01 available at www.cri.cn

12. TIN, 6 August 2001, www.tibetinfo.net/news-updates

13. China’s Vice-Minister of Agriculture, Qin Jingfa, was quoted as saying that “Nomadic life in China will cease to exist by the end of the century”, Xinhua, March 1998

14. J. Charles, Livelihoods Lost? Globalisation, WTO Accession and the Future of the Tibetan People, Free Tibet Campaign, London, November 2001

15. TCHRD Interview 30, 3 August 2001, see Case Study, Appendix

16. TCHRD Interview 44, 11 February 2000

17. TCHRD Interview 44, 11 February 2000

18. TCHRD Interview 52, 27 November 2000

19. TCHRD Interview 4/371, January 2001

20. TCHRD Interview 64, 30 July 2001

21. TCHRD Interview 30, 3 August 2001; see Case Study, Appendix

22. TCHRD Interview 45, 20 March 2000

23. Tibet 2000: Environment and Development Issues, p.48

24. TCHRD Interview 5/406, 20 June 2001

25. TCHRD Interview 34, 8 August 2001

26. TCHRD Interview 5/412, 25 July 2001

27. Feng Jing, Beijing Review, “Tax Reform Helps Ease Burden on Farmers”, 8 November 2001, located at www.bjreview.com.cn/bjreview/EN/NationalIssues/China200118b.html

28. TCHRD Interview 4/377, 12 March 2001; see case study 3 in Appendix

29. ibid

30. TCHRD Interview 5/446, 12 November 2001, TCHRD Interview 52, 27 November 2000, see Case Study, Appendix

31. Beijing Review, “Tax Reform Helps Ease Burden on Farmers”, 8 November 2001

32. ibid

33. A. Forbes and C. McGranahan, Developing Tibet? A Survey of International Development Projects, ICT, Washinton D. C., USA, 1992

34. ibid

35. TCHRD Interview 24, 8 August 2001

36. Botanical name is cordyceps sinensis and the literal translation is “summer grass/winter wool” but is also described as “caterpillar fungus”

37. For a list of articles about cordyceps sinensis, see www.personalhealthfacts.com/energy/

38. TCHRD Interview 33, 23 November 2000

39. TCHRD Interview 4/381, 11 April 2001, see Case Study, Appendix

40. TCHRD Interview 30, 3 August 2001; see Case Study, Appendix

41 TCHRD Interview 22, 20 August 2001

42 TIN, “Initial Reports on Fourth Tibet Work Forum”, 27 July 2001,www.tibetinfo.net/news-updates

43 Article 11 of ICESCR

44. Article 8 of ICESCR

45. Article 45 Constitution of PRC

46. Information Office of the State Council, White Paper on the Development-Oriented Poverty Reduction Programme, Beijing, 15 October 2001, from Xinhuanet

47. ibid

48. Information Office of the State Council, White Paper on Tibet’s March Towards Modernization, 8 November 2001, from Xinhuanet

49. World Bank, China Development Brief, http://www.chinadevelopmentbrief.com/brief.asp; for a detailed commentary on China’s fabrication or manipulation of statistics, see DIIR, Height of Darkness: Chinese Colonialism on the World’s Roof, Dharamsala, India, December 2001

50. For example TCHRD Interview 8, 6 August 2001 Tibetan from Ngamring County, Shigatse Prefecture, “TAR”; Tibetan from Henan County, Malho “TAP”, Qinghai: TCHRD Interview 52, 27 November 2000); Tibetan from Saga County, Shigatse Prefecture, TAP: TCHRD Interview 65, 18 July 2001; Tibetan from Karze County, Karze “TAP”, Sichuan: TCHRD Interview 67, 27 August 2001

51. Testimonies by a man from Gongkar county, Lhokha Prefecture, “TAR” (TCHRD Interview 27, 21 September 2001) who says that the government doesn’t give any grains, but that poor people must borrow from wealthier families; a farmer from Tingri County, Shigatse Prefecture, “TAR”, says that government assistance for poor people is only enough for three families, so at least eight families out of 22 in the township are completely dependant on loans for their day-to-day living: TCHRD Interview 4/400, 21 June 2001

52. TCHRD Interview 17, 11 June 2001, see Case Study, Appendix

53. White Paper on the Development-orientated Poverty Reduction Programme

54. TCHRD Interview 5/446, 12 November 2001; see case study 1 in Appendix

55. White Paper on the Development-orientated Poverty Reduction Programme

56. TCHRD Interview 5/409, 22 July 2001

57. Article 17 of ICCPR – for more information regarding freedom of movement, see the Chapter on Civil and Political Rights

58. TCHRD Interview 5/406, 20 June 2001: a farming family who made 3,000 yuan from wood-chopping was issued a receipt by the forestry department stating that they had made 10,000 yuan; TCHRD Interview 54, 24 January 2001

59. TCHRD Interview 54, 24 January 2001

60. Article 25 ICESCR, also see Article 1 ICESCR

61. Article 1(2) UNDRD

62. Livelihoods Lost? Globalisation, WTO Accession and the Future of the Tibetan People

63. TCHRD Interview 9, 3 April 2001; see case study 6 in Appendix

64. TCHRD Interview 14, 2 May 2001

65. TCHRD Interview 38, 23 November 2000

66. Tibet Under Communist China: 50 years, pp 53-54; Tibet 2000: Environment and Development Issues, p. 52

67. TIN, “Personal view: Tibetan perspectives on Lhasa today”, 27 December 2000, www.tibetinfo.net/news-updates

68. TCHRD Interview 5/406, 20 June 2001

69. TCHRD interview 4 /386, 20 April 2001

70. The Times of India, “China puts infrastructure first in western push”, 2 August 2001

71. TCHRD interview 5/428, 13 September 2001, TCHRD interview 5/429, 18 September 2001, see Case Study, Appendix

72. ibid

73. TCHRD Interview 4/370, 23 January 2001; see case study 9 in Appendix

74. ibid

75. Tibet 2000: Environment and Development Issues, p. 36

76. TCHRD Interview 69, 29 May 2001; TCHRD Interview 13, 30 April 2001; also see “The Right to Housing”

77. International Commission of Jurists, Tibet: Human rights and Rule of Law, Switzerland, 1997, p. 108

78. Xizang Ribao, 21 January 1993

79. White Paper on the Development-Oriented Poverty Reduction Programme

80. TIN, 27 July 2001, www.tibetinfo.net/news-updates

81. TIN, 6 April 2001, www.tibetinfo.net/news-updates; for an analysis of the possible effect of the railway on Tibet, see DIIR, China’s Railway Project: Where Will it take Tibet?, Dharamsala India, August 2001

82. ibid

83. Beijing China Internet Information Centre, 4 June 2001

84. TCHRD Interview 5/435, 25 October 2001

85. TIN “Dramatic transformation of Lhasa planned; new railway station announced”, 13 June 2001, www.tibetinfo.net/news-updates

86. ibid

87. ibid

88. TCHRD Interview 5/436, 22 October 2001

89. TCHRD Interview 4/372, 24 January 2001.

90. Article 7 ICESCR .

91. Article 7 (a)(i) ICESCR

92. Article 7 (b) ICESCR

93. Article 7(c) ICESCR

94. Article 7 (d) ICESCR

95. Article 42 of the Constitution of the PRC

96. Article 4 of the Constitution of the PRC

97. TCHRD Interview 67, 13 September 2001

98. TCHRD Interview 4/435, 25 October 2001, see Case Study, Appendix

99. ibid

100. TCHRD Interview 4/400, 21 June 2001

100. White Paper on Tibet’s March Toward Modernisation

102. TCHRD Interview 5/446, 28 November 2001, see Case Study, Appendix

103. TCHRD Interview 4/394 , 25 May 2001

104. TCHRD Interview 1, 21 November 2001, see Chapter on Education

105. TCHRD Interview 68, 4 June 2001; case study 10 in Appendix

106. Tibet Daily, 9 June 2001, cited in TIN, “Increase in Chinese medium teaching in Tibetan schools”, 27 November 2001, www.tibetinfo.net/news-updates

107. TCHRD Interview number 14, 2 May, 2001

108. ibid

109. TCHRD Interview 68, 4 June 2001, see Case Study, Appendix

110. ibid

111. ibid

112. TIN, 27 December 2000

113. ibid

114. TCHRD Interview, June 2001

115 Article 1 ILO Convention (No. 105) specifically outlaws members of the ILO using forced or compulsory labour as a means of political education, as a punishment for political expression, or as a means of mobilising labour for the purposes of economic development. Although China has refused to sign this Convention, the ILO has found that by being a member, it has committed itself to uphold international standards: see Declaration on Fundamental Principles and Rights at Work passed at the International Labour Conference, 19 June 1998. In addition, Article 6 of ICESCR gives people the right to gain a living by freely choosing work; in forcing people to work, “re-education through labour” clearly breaches this right; Article 9 of the ICCPR prohibits arbitrary detention and gives people the right to appeal to a court against their detention; Article 14 of ICCPR states that people are innocent unless proven guilty by a court

116. Human Rights Watch, “Re-education Through Labour in China”, www.hrw.org

117. See Chapter on Civil and Political Rights

118. TCHRD Interview 5/434, October 2001

119. Opening Address by UN Commissioner for Human Rights, Mary Robinson, at the “Workshop on Punishment of Minor Crimes”, Beijing, 26-27 February 2001, www.un.org

120. White Paper on Tibet’s March Toward Modernisation

121. UNDP, China Human Development Report, 1997 and 1999

122. Bruce Murray, representative for the Asian Development Bank in China, The Times of India, “China puts Infrastructure First in Western Push”, 2 August 2001

123. Amartya Sen, Development as Freedom, Oxford University Press, 1999, pp.150-151

124. ibid

125. TIN, “National autonomy law revised to support western development policy”, 13 March 2001, available at www.tibetinfo.org

126. Xinhua, 28 February 2001; also see Information Office of the State Council, Progress in China’s Human Rights Cause 2000, Beijing, April 2001

127. TIN, “Grass roots control stepped up with education of Chinese and Tibetan cadres”, 11 January 2001, www.tibetinfo.net/news-updates

128. Report of the Ad Hoc Committee of the Whole of the twenty-fourth special session of the General Assembly UN Doc. A/S-24/8/Rev.1

129. TCHRD Interview KTM 5/446, 11 November 2001; See Case Study, Appendix

130. TIN, 11 January 2001

131. TCHRD Interview 44, 11 February 2000

132. Statement by H.E. Vice Minister Long Yongtu at the 18th Session of the WTO Working party on China, 17 September 2001, available at www.wto.org

133. Livelihoods Lost? Globalisation, WTO Accession and the Future of the Tibetan People, p.3

134. White Paper on Tibet’s March Toward Modernization

135. Campaign for a Free Tibet, “WTO entry could hit Tibet farmers: rights group”, 9 November 2001, reported by AFP

136. Livelihoods Lost? Globalisation, WTO Accession and the Future of the Tibetan People

137. White Paper on the Development-Oriented Poverty Reduction Programme

138. Clay Chandler and Phillip P. Pan, Washington Post Foreign Service, “China’s Leaders Uneasy about WTO Entry”, 13 November 2001

139. Quote from Yuan Gangmin, Chinese Academy of Social Sciences, ibid.

140. White Paper on the Development-Oriented Poverty Reduction Programme.

141. ibid

142. ICLT, “Human Rights and the Long-Term Viability of Tibet’s Economy”, paper presented at APEC People’s Summit, Vancouver, Canada, November 1997

143. See for example Gabriel Lafitte, “World Bank Tsaidam Population Transfer Project”, TIN Update, 29 March 1999. The Tibetan Government in Exile has formulated “Guidelines for International Development Projects and Sustainable Investment in Tibet”, see Tibet 2000: Environment and Development Issues

144. It has been estimated that one million livelihoods were lost in the Mexican maize sector after initiation of NAFTA, and almost the same number in the Indian oilseeds sector: Livelihoods Lost? Globalisation, WTO Accession and the Future of the Tibetan People, p.8

145. “United Nations NGO Forum Declaration”, World Conference Against Racism, Durban , South Africa, 3 September 2001, paragraph 25 <--- END THE RIGHT TO LIVELIHOOD --->


[ Next: The Right to Education - Notes --> ]
[ Back to Chapter 1 ] [ Contents ] [ Recommendations ]